Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

10.1 — Before Socrates: The First People Who Asked What Things Are Made Of ​

Around 600 BCE, in a Greek trading city on the coast of what is now Turkey, somebody asked a question that nobody had asked in that form before.

**Not "who made the world" — every culture had an answer to that. "What is the world made of?"

The difference is that the second question expects an answer you could check.

Miletus ​

The city was Miletus, a wealthy port with contact across the Mediterranean and into Mesopotamia and Egypt. Trade, foreigners, competing stories about the gods, and money. Exactly the conditions that produced the Buddha's century in India (6.1), at almost exactly the same time.

Thales, around 585 BCE. He said everything is water.

Which sounds foolish and is not. Look at the reasoning: water is the only substance he knew that appears as solid, liquid and gas; life requires it; it is everywhere. He is proposing a single underlying substance that takes different forms.

What matters most is the kind of answer he gave, more than the answer itself. There are no gods here, no story and no family tree of gods. It is a natural explanation. It is put forward as a claim about how things are, and it is open to disagreement.

He is also credited with predicting a solar eclipse in 585 BCE, which if true means he was using Babylonian astronomical records, and which either way tells you what kind of person he was.

Anaximander, his student, disagreed. He said the basic stuff cannot be any of the familiar things, because if it were water then fire could not exist. So he proposed apeiron — the boundless, the indefinite — an unlimited something from which the opposites separate out.

That is an abstract theoretical entity, invented because the observable candidates fail. It is a genuinely sophisticated intellectual move and it is happening in the second generation.

He also said the earth floats free in space, held by nothing. His reason was that nothing makes it move in one direction rather than another, so it stays where it is. This is a symmetry argument, made in the sixth century BCE. He also said the first humans developed from fish-like creatures, because human infants cannot survive alone and so could not have been the first form.

Anaximenes said the first substance is air. He said air becomes thicker or thinner, which is called condensing and rarefying. His real contribution is the mechanism. One substance, changing in density, produces everything. More or less of the same stuff gives a different kind of thing.

The two positions everything after runs between ​

Heraclitus ​

From Ephesus, around 500 BCE, and he wrote in deliberately compressed, oracular fragments.

Everything flows. You cannot step into the same river twice, because new water is flowing.

And the sharper claim: the stability you see is not the absence of change but a pattern in it. The river is a stable thing made entirely of motion. A flame keeps its shape while nothing in it stays.

And: conflict is the father of all things. Opposites in tension are what produce a stable structure, the way a bow works only because the string pulls against the wood.

His underlying substance is fire, which is not a substance at all but a process, and that is the point.

Parmenides ​

And the exact opposite, from a Greek city in southern Italy.

His argument is pure logic and it is genuinely hard to escape.

Whatever is, is. What is not, is not. What is not cannot be spoken of or thought about, because to think about nothing is to think about nothing.

So nothing can come into being, because it would have to come from what is not. Nothing can perish, because it would have to become what is not. Nothing can change, because change means being what you were not.

So reality is one thing. It is unchanging, indivisible and eternal. The world of change that your senses report is not the truth.

This is the first time anybody argued that reason should be trusted over the senses when they conflict, and the whole subsequent history of philosophy is downstream of it.

His student Zeno defended it with paradoxes. Achilles cannot overtake the tortoise, because by the time he reaches where it was, it has moved on, and so on infinitely. An arrow in flight is, at each instant, at rest in a space equal to itself, so how does it move?

Zeno's paradoxes were not fully resolved until the mathematics of infinite series and limits was developed — Volume II covers that — and they were not silly. They were pointing at something real about the continuum.

A large Renaissance fresco showing a crowd of ancient philosophers gathered under a vast classical arch, with two central figures walking forward
Raphael's School of Athens, painted 1509–1511. Plato and Aristotle are at the centre — Plato pointing up towards the forms, Aristotle gesturing out at the world. Heraclitus sits alone on the steps at the front, and the figures scattered around them are most of this chapter and the next four. Image: Wikimedia Commons.

The attempted resolutions ​

Everything after Parmenides is an attempt to save the appearances without abandoning his logic.

Empedocles: He said there are four elements. They are earth, water, air and fire. They do not come into being or perish. They only mix and separate. Change is rearrangement, so nothing actually comes from nothing. Two forces drive the mixing and separating, which he called Love and Strife.

Anaxagoras: He said everything contains a portion of everything. Change is a change in proportion. He also introduced nous, which means mind, as the ordering principle. This is the first appearance of intelligence as a cause of the cosmos.

He also said the sun is a red-hot stone larger than the Peloponnese and that the moon is made of earth and reflects the sun's light, for which he was prosecuted for impiety and had to leave Athens.

And Democritus and Leucippus: atoms and void.

The atomists ​

Because this is the one that turned out closest to right, and the reasoning deserves setting out.

If matter were divisible without limit, then dividing completely would leave nothing, and you could not reassemble something from nothing. Therefore division terminates in indivisible units — atomos, "uncuttable."

The same argument the Vaisheshika school made in India (9.6), apparently independently.

And Democritus's system: atoms differ only in shape, size, arrangement and position. They move in a void — which required arguing that empty space exists, against Parmenides, who said what-is-not cannot be. Everything that happens is atoms colliding and combining, with no purpose and no design.

He said that sweet, bitter, hot, cold and colour exist only by convention. In reality there are only atoms and void. Here is a distinction between what a thing is and how it appears to the one who perceives it. It was made in the fifth century BCE.

The sophists ​

And the last group before Socrates, who are usually dismissed and should not be.

They were professional teachers who charged fees, mostly for rhetoric and argument, in a democracy where the ability to persuade an assembly determined everything.

Protagoras taught that "man is the measure of all things, of those that are that they are, and of those that are not that they are not." This is relativism, stated for the first time. On the gods he wrote that "concerning the gods I cannot know whether they exist or not, or what they are like; many things prevent knowledge, the obscurity of the subject and the shortness of human life."

They were detested for charging money and for teaching people to argue either side of a case. The second charge is the more interesting of the two. Teaching someone to argue both sides is either sophistry or the beginning of critical thinking. Sophistry means clever arguing that does not look for the truth. Volume VI recommends the same habit, which it calls being your own devil's advocate.

What this founding period established ​

Three things, and they are the reason it matters.

That the world has a natural explanation and that you can look for it. Every science descends from this.

That reason and the senses can conflict, and that this is a real problem. Parmenides opened it and nobody has closed it (15.2).

A claim should be argued for, not just stated. Thales said water. Anaximander said no, and gave his reasons. A tradition of disagreement began in the first generation, and it has never stopped.

What to carry from this page ​

The question "what is it made of" expects a checkable answer, and "who made it" does not. Almost all intellectual progress consists of converting the second kind of question into the first.

The stability you see may be a pattern in motion rather than the absence of it. Heraclitus's river, and 15.3 says the physics agrees.

When reason and observation conflict, something interesting is happening, and both of the available responses — trust the argument, trust the eyes — have been wrong at various times.

The atomic argument arose independently in Greece and in India, from the same reasoning about divisibility, which asks whether a thing can be cut in half forever. Two traditions that were cut off from each other reached the same conclusion by the same route. That deserves our attention.

Next: 10.2 — a man who wrote nothing, taught nothing, claimed to know nothing, and changed everything.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet