Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

10.3 — Plato ​

He was about twenty-eight when Athens executed his teacher, and everything he wrote afterwards is downstream of that.

He founded the Academy, which ran for nearly nine hundred years. He wrote dialogues rather than treatises, which are formal essays. Socrates is usually the main speaker. This makes it permanently unclear where Socrates ends and Plato begins.

The forms ​

His central claim, and it grows directly out of Socrates' failure to get definitions (10.2).

Socrates asked what justice is and nobody could say. Plato's answer: they could not say because they were looking in the wrong place.

Consider a circle. Every physical circle is imperfect. It is drawn with a shaking hand. It is made of atoms. It is never exactly circular. Yet you know exactly what a circle is, and you can prove things about it that are perfectly true.

So what are you knowing about? Not any particular circle, because they are all defective. The Circle itself.

**And Plato generalises: for every quality — beauty, justice, equality, goodness, largeness — there is a Form, which is perfect, unchanging, and not located in space or time. Physical things are what they are by participating in the Forms, imperfectly and temporarily.

Which means the world you can see is the world of copies, and the real world is the one you can only reach by thinking.

Parmenides' unchanging reality (10.1), rescued and made to explain the changing one.

The cave ​

And the image, which is the most famous passage in Western philosophy.

Prisoners are chained in a cave, facing a wall, since childhood. They cannot turn their heads.

Behind them is a fire, and between the fire and the prisoners a walkway along which people carry objects, casting shadows on the wall.

The prisoners see the shadows and hear the echoes, and they name them, and compete at predicting which shadow comes next, and honour whoever is best at it.

Shadows are all the reality they know.

Now free one. He turns, and the fire hurts his eyes, and the objects look less real to him than the shadows did. Drag him up the passage into the sunlight and he is blinded and in pain, and he would go back.

Slowly his eyes adjust. He sees shadows first, then reflections, then objects, and finally the sun itself. He understands that the sun is the cause of everything he now sees.

And then he goes back down.

His eyes, adjusted to the light, cannot see in the dark. He is worse than the others at the shadow-game. They conclude that going up ruined his sight, that nobody should attempt it, and that anyone who tried to free them should be killed.

Plato wrote that fewer than thirty years after Athens killed Socrates.

Reading the cave ​

Three levels, and all three are intended.

Metaphysical: the physical world is the shadows and the Forms are the objects.

Educational: learning is painful, disorienting, and initially makes you worse at the game everybody is playing. The freed prisoner is not immediately better off, and this is the honest part.

And political: the person who has seen must return, and will be laughed at, and may be killed.

Notice one detail that matters a great deal. The prisoners' competence is real. They are genuinely good at predicting shadows. The problem is not that they are stupid. The problem is that their whole skill applies to something they have mistaken for reality, and nothing they can experience inside the cave would show them the mistake.

The tripartite soul ​

And the psychology, which has held up better than the metaphysics.

Three parts.

Reason — which wants truth.

Spirit — the part that is indignant, competitive, ashamed, and wants honour. Not emotion in general; specifically the honour-seeking, self-respecting part.

Appetite — hunger, thirst, sex, money.

The image is a chariot: a driver with two horses, one noble and one unruly.

Justice in a person is each part doing its own work, with reason in charge. Plato does not say that reason should destroy the others. He says plainly that it should not. Spirit's job is to be reason's ally against runaway appetite.

The observation that makes it convincing is a simple one. Plato tells of a man who wants to look at corpses. He is disgusted with himself for wanting to. He looks anyway, cursing his own eyes. One part of him wants to look, and another part is ashamed of the wanting. Plato saw this conflict directly.

The three parts show up again in later psychology. Freud's picture of the mind is essentially this one with different names. Chapter 5.8 describes the gunas, which are another three-part picture of a person, from a different tradition.

The Republic ​

The just city, constructed as an analogy for the just soul, and it is where Plato is at his most brilliant and his most alarming.

Three classes matching the three parts: rulers (reason), guardians (spirit), producers (appetite).

Rulers are philosophers. They are selected by aptitude and educated for decades. They hold no private property and have no families of their own. Plato judged that property and family are what corrupt rulers.

And his argument for it is the strongest case against democracy ever made, and it deserves to be stated properly.

If you are sick you want a doctor, not a vote. If you are sailing you want a navigator. Governing is a skill like any other, and there is no reason to think a majority of untrained people will choose well. Athens voted for the Sicilian expedition and destroyed itself; Athens voted to kill Socrates.

Plato does not answer the reply to this view well. It asks three questions. Who guards the guardians? How do you identify the wise without already being wise? What happens when the rulers are wrong and there is no way to remove them? Twentieth-century critics called the Republic the first blueprint for totalitarianism. The charge is not baseless. The book includes censorship of poetry, state control of reproduction, and a founding myth to be told to citizens for their own good.

What is defensible: the diagnosis. Plato is right that democracy has no mechanism for ensuring competence and that voters can be flattered. His solution is worse than the problem, and the problem is real.

What lasted ​

Four things.

The distinction between appearance and reality, which structures all Western philosophy after him.

The idea that mathematics tells you about something real. Many mathematicians are Platonists to this day. They feel that they are discovering mathematics rather than inventing it. Volume II discusses why.

The tripartite soul, which is the ancestor of every model of internal conflict.

And the dialogue form itself. Philosophy as a conversation with objections built in, rather than a treatise.

The criticisms ​

Aristotle's, made by his own student, is the sharpest and is in 10.4: the Forms explain nothing, because saying a thing is beautiful by participating in Beauty just gives the problem a name.

The modern criticism is that Plato's real world is out of reach, never changes, and is known only by pure thought. This turned out to be the wrong bet. The world of change and observation is the one he treated as second-rate. Every discovery of the last four hundred years has come from it.

What to carry from this page ​

The prisoners are good at the game. They can be truly skilled at something that is not what they think it is. This is the real danger. Nothing inside the cave shows them the mistake.

Learning makes you worse before it makes you better, and it makes you bad at the thing everybody else is scoring.

Reason, spirit and appetite are the three parts. Spirit's job is to be reason's ally. The part of you that is ashamed of what you want is not the enemy.

And Plato's case against democracy is a real case. The answer to it is not that he was silly; it is that his alternative has no error-correction and democracy does.

Next: 10.4 — his student, who disagreed with almost everything and invented most of the categories everybody still uses.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet