Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

6.2 — The Palace, the Four Sights, and the Leaving ​

The story as it is usually told: a prince is kept inside a palace where nothing unpleasant is permitted, because a prophecy said he would become either a great king or a great renunciate and his father wanted the first. At twenty-nine he goes out and sees four things he has never seen. He leaves that night.

The four sights: an old man, a sick man, a corpse, and a wandering ascetic.

Now the honest version, which is better.

What the earliest account says ​

In the oldest layer of the texts, there is no palace of total isolation and there are no four encounters on a road.

There is something more interesting: he tells it himself, in the first person, as a psychological observation.

He says, in substance: I was delicately brought up. I had every comfort. Then it occurred to me that I am subject to ageing myself. Why do I look at another ageing person and feel repelled? I am subject to sickness and death too. Why do I recoil from a sick person, or from a dead one?

And he says: when I considered this, all intoxication with youth, with health, and with life, entirely fell away.

That is the actual reported event. It was not four encounters. It was a realisation about a mistake he had been making his whole life. He had been treating other people's decay as something that happens to them.

Why this version is stronger ​

Because everybody has done exactly this and it is completely recognisable.

You know that you will get old. You do not believe it. You see an elderly person struggling, and something in you files it under them, not under me in forty years. The Yaksha said the same thing in 3.10. Everybody watches others die and expects to be the exception. It is the same observation from a different tradition.

The four sights version turns a universal error into a story about a sheltered prince, which is more dramatic and lets you off. You are not a prince and you have seen sick people, so the story is about somebody else.

The first-person version does not let you off at all.

The palace, read properly ​

And there was probably something like a palace, in the sense that matters.

He describes it himself. There were three houses for the three seasons, lotus ponds, attendants, the finest food and musicians. Then comes the detail that gives it away. He was kept indoors during the rains so he would not be troubled.

That is not a prison. It is a very comfortable life among a leading family of a small republic. What matters here is not that he never saw anything unpleasant.

Comfort is like an anaesthetic. An anaesthetic is a medicine that stops you feeling pain. A very pleasant life makes the facts about ageing and death feel distant. They are not hidden. There is simply always something more immediate. You do not need a palace for that. A busy month does it.

And the escape is not from the palace. It is from the anaesthesia, which is why the leaving happens the way it does.

The night ​

Here is the famous version. He looks at his sleeping wife and newborn son and does not wake them. He rides out with his charioteer Channa. At the river he cuts his hair. Then he sends the horse and the man back.

And the fact that has to be dealt with: he abandoned a wife and a newborn child.

This book will not smooth that over. Later traditions worked hard on it. In them, Yashodhara is given a vision, or consent, or a previous-life arrangement. The early material does not soften it much. He left. Rahula was days old.

Judging the leaving ​

Three things, and they do not all point one way.

In his society, the arrangement was less brutal than it sounds. He left a wife and child inside an extended aristocratic household with wealth, status and many relatives. They were not destitute and not alone. The practice of a man leaving for the religious life was recognised, had a name, and happened regularly. It was not unusual and it was not illegal.

And it was still an abandonment, and 4.7 already made the general point: an explanation addresses the reasons, and the person left behind is not confused about the reasons.

And the story does not end there, which is the part usually missed. Both of them join him later. Yashodhara becomes a nun. Rahula is ordained as a boy and becomes a monk of the community. Mahaprajapati, who raised him, leads the campaign for women's ordination (6.11). His father comes and hears him teach.

The family he left reassembled around him, which is not a defence of the leaving and is a real fact about what followed.

What the leaving is actually for ​

The tradition's word is pabbajja, which means "going forth." It names a specific and recognisable move.

He had a good life and a real problem, and the good life was preventing him from working on the problem.

Not because it was bad. Because it was absorbing. Every hour was accounted for, every comfort was available, and there was no space in which the question could be worked on.

And here is the general form, which is what makes this chapter useful to somebody who is not going to leave anything.

A comfortable and busy life is not neutral toward your real questions. It actively prevents them. It does not forbid them. It fills the space where they would occur. Some people say they will think about what they actually want once things calm down. They have made a mistake. Things do not calm down, and the filling is not temporary.

The Buddha's response was extreme and total. Yours does not have to be, and something has to be, or the question will not get worked on.

The practical minimum is unglamorous: unfilled time, regularly, with nothing to consume in it. No input. The question will arrive on its own within about twenty minutes, which is why almost nobody does this and why every contemplative tradition ever founded insists on it.

Channa and the horse ​

One small detail worth keeping.

He sends the charioteer and the horse back, and Channa does not want to go. The horse, in the tradition, dies of grief.

It is a sentimental detail and it is doing something. The leaving costs other people, and the story keeps the cost visible rather than making the departure clean. Even the horse is not spared.

Every significant departure in this volume has this shape. Rama's exile cost Sita, Urmila and a kingdom (2.3, 2.5). Krishna's leaving cost Vrindavan permanently (4.7). The Buddha's cost a wife, a son, a father and a charioteer.

None of these people were asked.

What to carry from this page ​

The realisation is not "people die." It is "I am the same kind of thing." You know the first and you do not believe the second, and the difference between those two states is the entire event described on this page.

Comfort is an anaesthetic and busyness is the delivery system. Neither is bad and both prevent the work.

Leave unfilled time with no input in it. Twenty minutes is enough for the question to arrive. That is the version of going forth available to a person with a job and a family.

And whatever you leave, somebody pays for it who was not asked. Do not tell yourself the departure was clean. None of them are.

Next: 6.3 tells of six years of doing it wrong. It tells of two teachers he outgrew and a body reduced to almost nothing. It ends with the moment he remembered something from childhood that changed everything.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet