Appearance
10.6 — Epicurus and the Cynics
Two schools, contemporary with early Stoicism, and both misunderstood in the same way: their names became English words that mean roughly the opposite of what they taught.
Epicurus
"Epicurean" now means a person devoted to fine food and luxury.
Epicurus lived on bread and water, with cheese as an occasional treat, and wrote that he was thrilled by a small pot of cheese when he wanted to feast.
The actual doctrine
Pleasure is the highest good and pain is the only evil. That much is correct.
And then the analysis, which is where everything changes.
For Epicurus, pleasure is mostly the absence of pain. There are two kinds. Ataraxia is freedom from disturbance in the mind. Aponia is freedom from pain in the body. Pleasure is not a strong sensation to be piled up as high as possible. It is a settled, calm condition.
Which means the way to maximise pleasure is to eliminate disturbance rather than to add stimulation.
And he classifies desires, which is the practical core.
Natural and necessary: food, water, shelter, safety, friendship. Easily satisfied, and satisfying them removes real pain.
Natural but unnecessary: rich food, sex, a comfortable house. Fine to enjoy, not worth arranging your life around.
The last kind is neither natural nor necessary. It includes wealth, fame, power and status. These are the desires that cannot be satisfied, because they have no natural limit. This is the lobha of 8.8, found there by the same reasoning.
And the argument: the first category is cheap and easy, and almost all human misery comes from pursuing the third.
The four-part cure
His summary, the tetrapharmakos:
Do not fear god. The gods, if they exist, are perfectly happy and take no interest in human affairs. Religion's main function, in his view, was the manufacture of fear.
Do not worry about death. The argument: death is the end of sensation, and what is not experienced is not bad for you. Where death is, I am not; where I am, death is not. And he adds: you do not fear the infinite time before your birth, and it is the same thing.
What is good is easy to get.
What is terrible is easy to endure, he says, because severe pain is short and chronic pain is mild. This is his weakest claim. It plainly does not hold for some conditions.
Friendship
And the thing he valued most, which surprises people.
Of all the things wisdom provides for a happy life, he said, by far the greatest is friendship.
His school, the Garden, was a community outside Athens where people lived together. It admitted women and slaves. This was scandalous at the time. It is one of the earliest such arrangements in the West.
And his advice was to withdraw from public life. Live unnoticed. Politics is a source of disturbance with no natural limit, and the way to be untroubled is to keep out of it.
Which is the exact opposite of Stoic and Aristotelian advice (10.4, 10.5), and it is the school's most contested position.
The last letter
He died of kidney stones, in severe pain.
On his last day he wrote to a friend. On this blessed day, which is also the last of my life, I write this to you. My continual sufferings are such that nothing could increase them. But over against them all I set gladness of mind at the remembrance of our past conversations.
A man testing his own doctrine under maximum load and reporting that it held.
The Cynics
**"Cynical" now means distrustful and sneering. The word comes from kyon, dog — they were called the dog philosophers, as an insult, and they adopted it.
Diogenes
The founder in practice, and most of what survives is anecdotes, which is appropriate for a school that rejected doctrine.
He lived in a large ceramic jar in Athens. He owned a cloak, a stick and a bag. He threw away his drinking cup after seeing a child drink from cupped hands.
He carried a lit lamp in daylight, and when asked what he was doing, said he was looking for an honest man.
Alexander the Great came to see him, stood over him and offered him anything he wanted. Diogenes asked him to move slightly, because he was blocking the sun. Alexander is reported to have said afterwards that if he were not Alexander, he would want to be Diogenes.
Asked where he was from, he said he was a citizen of the world. The Greek word is kosmopolites. This is the first recorded use of the idea of world citizenship. It is no small thing to have invented while living in a jar.
The doctrine
Because there is one under the theatre.
Everything that makes people miserable is convention. Property, reputation, status, manners, shame and the piling up of things are not natural. People have agreed to them, and they can be put aside.
Virtue is living in accordance with nature, which means: what an animal needs, and nothing else.
The method was to break convention on purpose, in public. The aim was to show that the conventions are arbitrary, and that nothing happens when you break them. Diogenes ate in the marketplace, which was considered shocking. He also did other things in public that are still shocking, and this book will not describe them.
What is actually valuable
Two things, and they survive the theatre.
The demonstration that most needs are manufactured. Diogenes is a proof of concept: a person can live with almost nothing and be visibly happier than the people he is mocking. You do not have to imitate him to have absorbed the point.
The willingness to be laughed at is the other lesson. This is the practice of 8.9, lived out as a whole life. A person who has no reputation to protect cannot be controlled by the threat of losing it. Diogenes shows the extreme case of what that gives you. It even gave him the freedom to tell Alexander to move.
The line to Stoicism
There is also a historical link between the Cynics and the Stoics.
Zeno, the founder of Stoicism, studied with a Cynic teacher.
Stoicism is Cynicism made to fit ordinary life. It keeps the core claim. The claim is that what disturbs you is your judgement about outside things, and not the things themselves. It drops the requirement to live in a jar.
Which is why Stoicism spread and Cynicism did not. A philosophy that requires public indecency and homelessness has a limited market, and the Stoics kept the insight and made it usable.
The two schools compared
Both agree that most human misery is self-inflicted and unnecessary.
Both agree that the pursuit of wealth, status and fame is the main source of it.
They differ on the remedy.
Epicurus: withdraw quietly, cultivate friendship, satisfy the natural desires cheaply, and let the rest go.
Diogenes: reject the whole apparatus publicly and mock it.
And a third position — the Stoic one — engage fully, in public life, without depending on any of it (10.5).
Three answers to the same diagnosis, and 16.4 is where this volume takes a position on which is available to you.
What to carry from this page
Sort your desires into three categories: natural and necessary, natural and unnecessary, and neither. The third category is where the misery is, and it has no natural limit.
"Where death is, I am not." Epicurus's argument is genuinely good and 14.2 tests it properly.
Of everything that produces a happy life, friendship is the greatest. Said by a man who built a community and tested it while dying of kidney stones.
And a person with no reputation to protect cannot be controlled by the threat of losing it. You do not need the jar to use this.
Next: 10.7 — a thousand years in which the central question was whether reason and faith can occupy the same mind.