Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

12.4 — Judaism, Christianity, Islam: The Shared Root and the Real Differences ​

Three traditions, roughly 3.9 billion people between them, all tracing to the same figure and the same claim.

And the differences between them are frequently described by their partisans and almost never described neutrally, so this chapter does that.

The shared root ​

All three trace to Abraham, and all three make the same fundamental claim: there is one God, who is personal, who acts in history, and who has made demands of human beings.

This claim is distinctive. In Part 11 we saw that most traditions have many gods. Others hold an impersonal principle, or a divine that is the same as the world itself. A single, personal, moral God who acts in history and gives commands is a specific and unusual position.

They also share four more things. They see time as a line, not a circle. They expect a final judgement. They hold that prophets speak for God. They place scripture at the centre.

Judaism ​

The oldest, and the smallest — around 15 million people.

The central claim is not primarily about belief. It is covenant: an agreement between God and a specific people, with obligations on both sides.

And what follows from that shapes everything.

The obligations are detailed and practical. The tradition counts 613 commandments in the Torah. They cover food, farming, law, worship, family life, business and how to treat strangers.

And the intellectual life is legal. The Talmud — the record of centuries of rabbinic debate on how to apply the law — is enormous, and its characteristic feature is that it preserves the losing arguments. A page of Talmud typically has a text in the centre and layers of commentary and counter-commentary around it, from different centuries, disagreeing.

It is a tradition built around argument, not around a creed. A creed is a short statement of what everyone must believe. Judaism has no church hierarchy. It also has no single doctrinal authority.

No missionary activity. Conversion is possible and is traditionally discouraged rather than sought.

And on the afterlife: strikingly little. The Hebrew Bible says almost nothing about it. The tradition's focus is on this life and on this world, and the later development of ideas about a world to come is genuinely later.

One more thing belongs here. Jewish communities in Christian and Muslim societies suffered again and again. They faced expulsion, forced conversion, massacre and legal disability. In the twentieth century this reached its worst point in the industrialised murder of six million people. Volume VIII covers it. An account of these three traditions needs to include this history.

Christianity ​

The largest, around 2.4 billion.

A movement inside first-century Judaism that became a separate religion.

The central claim is a specific historical and religious one. Christians say that Jesus of Nazareth was the promised messiah. They say he was God made flesh. They say Roman authority executed him, and that he rose from the dead. They say this event changed the human relationship with God.

And the consequences of that shape everything.

It is belief-organised (12.1). Because the claim is a proposition about a specific person, holding the proposition is what membership means, and this is why Christianity produced creeds, councils, heresies and doctrinal splits on a scale the other two did not.

The law is superseded. Paul's argument — that gentile converts need not adopt Jewish law — is what made it a universal religion rather than a Jewish sect, and it is the most consequential decision in the tradition's history.

Salvation is by grace rather than by works, in most formulations, with a long argument about the relationship between the two which produced the Reformation.

And the Trinity: one God in three persons. This is genuinely difficult, was hammered out over four centuries of councils and disputes, and is the point at which the other two traditions object most strongly.

There are three main divisions. They are Orthodox, Catholic and Protestant. The Orthodox and Catholic churches separated in 1054. Protestantism began in the sixteenth century. It has since divided many times.

Islam ​

Around 1.9 billion, and the youngest of the three.

The central claim has three parts. God is absolutely one and cannot be divided. God has no partners and no offspring. Muhammad is the last in a line of prophets that includes Abraham, Moses and Jesus. The Quran is God's direct speech, revealed to him.

And each of those is doing specific work.

Tawhid, the oneness of God, is the foundation and it is uncompromising. The gravest error in Islam is shirk — associating anything with God — and this is precisely why the Trinity and the divinity of Jesus are rejected. Jesus is honoured as a prophet and a messiah; his divinity is not accepted.

The Quran is not analogous to the Bible. It is understood as God's own uncreated speech, in Arabic, which is why translation is regarded as interpretation rather than as the thing itself, and why memorisation of the whole text is a widespread practice.

The practice is clearly laid out. It is called the five pillars. The first is the declaration of faith. The second is prayer five times a day. The third is charity, given as a fixed share of wealth. The fourth is fasting during Ramadan. The fifth is pilgrimage to Mecca, once in a lifetime for those who are able.

Islam is built around practice more than Christianity is. It is built around belief more than Judaism is. It has no priesthood. Scholars have authority through learning, not through ordination, which means being formally appointed as a priest.

Islam also has a legal tradition called sharia. It was developed in schools of jurisprudence, which are schools of legal thought, and they disagree with each other a great deal. People often forget this when they talk about it.

The main division is between Sunni and Shia. It began in the seventh century, with a dispute over who should lead after Muhammad's death. Over time it grew into two distinct legal and theological traditions.

The real differences ​

Now the comparison, stated as neutrally as it can be.

On God's nature. Judaism: absolutely one, and covenanted with a people. Christianity: one in three persons, and incarnate. Islam: absolutely one, and utterly transcendent.

On Jesus. A first-century Jewish teacher, not the messiah (Judaism). God incarnate, risen (Christianity). A great prophet, born of a virgin, not divine, not crucified in most interpretations (Islam).

On scripture. In Judaism, the text needs to be interpreted through a continuing legal tradition. In Christianity, scripture is inspired, and who has authority to interpret it differs from one denomination to another. In Islam, the Quran is God's direct and uncreated speech.

On what is required. Observance of the covenant's obligations. Faith in Christ. Submission to God, expressed in the five pillars.

On who it is for. A specific people, with conversion possible and not sought. Everybody, and actively sought. Everybody, and actively sought.

On the afterlife. Judaism gives it comparatively little emphasis. In Christianity it is central. In Islam it is central too.

What they share ethically ​

And the overlap here is much larger than the doctrinal overlap, which is 12.9's general finding.

All three share many ethical teachings. They teach that there is one God who makes moral demands. They hold that caring for the poor is an obligation, and not only a kind thing to do. They forbid murder, theft, adultery and false witness. They teach honour for parents. They each set aside a special day or period.

All three have a version of the golden rule.

All three have a strong tradition of hospitality to strangers.

All three also developed rich mystical traditions. These are Kabbalah, Christian mysticism, and Sufism. They resemble each other far more than the mainstream traditions do. The mystics of all three were regarded with suspicion by their own institutions. The same thing happened in each of them.

What is worth being honest about ​

Three things.

The traditions have persecuted each other and their own dissenters, extensively, and 12.8 is the chapter for it.

The differences are real and are not dissolvable by goodwill. Whether Jesus was God is not a matter of emphasis. A conversation that pretends the three traditions agree is not respecting any of them.

The shared root is genuine. They read overlapping scriptures. They revere overlapping figures. They make the same basic claim about the kind of thing God is. This closeness is part of why the disputes have been so bitter. The conflicts between them have generally been sharper than their conflicts with traditions that share nothing with them.

Proximity is what produces this, and 8.9 said the same about envy: you do not fight across a gap you cannot imagine crossing.

What to carry from this page ​

Covenant, incarnation, submission. Three words for the three central relationships, and most of the differences follow from which one is at the centre.

Judaism keeps the losing arguments on the same page as the winning ones. This is a remarkable habit of mind, and any of us could learn from it.

The Quran is understood as God's direct speech rather than as an inspired text, which is why the relationship to translation is completely different from the Christian one.

And the mystics of all three resemble each other more than the mainstreams do, and were all viewed with suspicion by their own institutions. That is one of the most interesting facts in comparative religion and 12.9 takes it up.

Next: 12.5 — four smaller traditions, each of which solved a problem the large ones did not.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet