Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

3.10 — Thirteen Years: The Forest, the Yaksha's Questions, and the Year in Disguise ​

Twelve years in the forest, then one year in disguise, and if they are recognised during the thirteenth the whole term restarts.

The forest years are where the Mahabharata does most of its philosophy. The action stops, and argument fills the space. Most of it is between Draupadi and Yudhishthira, and it is one of the best things in the book.

The argument in the forest ​

Draupadi's position: She tells Yudhishthira that he was cheated and that his family was assaulted. He has the power to act, and yet he sits in a forest talking about righteousness. She accuses him of using dharma as a hiding place. Dharma is the word for duty, and for the right way to live and act. She says that a king who does not act is not being virtuous, he is being useless, and that his patience is being paid for by everybody around him.

Bhima agrees, loudly and constantly, for twelve years.

Yudhishthira's position: he gave his word. The terms were thirteen years. A man whose word holds only when it is convenient has no word. And he says something harder: that he is not being patient in order to win later, but because breaking the agreement would make him into the kind of person the agreement was supposed to prevent.

Neither convinces the other and the epic does not adjudicate, which by now you should expect.

What is worth taking from it is the shape of the disagreement, because it is one you will have. One person says: the rule is the rule and I will not become the thing I am opposing. The other says: your rule is costing other people and you are calling that virtue. Both are describing something real. The question that actually separates them is the one from 2.5: who pays? Yudhishthira's patience is paid for by Draupadi's thirteen years with loose hair. That does not make him wrong. It makes his position expensive in a currency he is not spending.

Arjuna goes for weapons ​

Arjuna leaves for several years to obtain divine weapons. In the plain reading, he goes to train with the best masters available and to secure alliances. He returns with a capability the Kauravas do not have, and it decides several days of the war.

The teaching is dry and it is one of the most practical in the Part: exile is preparation or it is nothing. Thirteen years is a long time. The Pandavas spend it acquiring weapons, allies, information and skills, and that is the entire reason they win. A forced pause used for training is a different object from a forced pause spent waiting.

The Yaksha's questions ​

This is the most quoted passage in the Mahabharata after the Gita, and it is the closest the epic comes to stating its own beliefs.

Late in the exile, thirsty, the brothers reach a lake. Yudhishthira sends Nakula for water. He does not return. Sahadeva, then Arjuna, then Bhima. None return.

Yudhishthira finds his four brothers dead by the water. A voice from the lake — a Yaksha, a nature spirit of the place (1.5) — says: this lake is mine. Answer my questions before you drink. They did not, and they died.

Yudhishthira answers.

The exchange runs to over a hundred questions. Here are the ones that matter, in plain English.

"What is heavier than the earth?" — A mother. "Higher than the sky?" — A father. "Faster than the wind?" — The mind. "More numerous than grass?" — Worries.

"What makes a man a Brahmin — birth, learning, or conduct?" — Conduct alone. Not birth, not study. This is stated flatly, in the middle of a text that elsewhere upholds hereditary caste, and it is one of the sharpest self-contradictions in the book. The epic argues with itself and this is the side it puts in the mouth of its most righteous character at the moment of maximum seriousness.

"What is the greatest wonder in the world?" — "Day after day, countless creatures die, and yet the ones who remain believe they will live forever. What could be more astonishing than that?"

This is the most famous line in the Mahabharata and it deserves a moment. He is not saying people fear death insufficiently. He is saying something more precise: everybody knows the fact and nobody has integrated it. You have watched people die. You know the rate is one hundred per cent. And you make plans, hold grudges for years, postpone the conversation, and behave in every practical respect as though the deadline does not apply to you. The whole of Part 14 grows out of this sentence.

"What is the path?" — Not argument, not scripture, not the opinions of learned men, because they disagree. The path is what good people have walked.

"What is true happiness?" — Living within your means, at home, having eaten simply. Not renunciation and not wealth. Enough, at home.

"What is the news?" — And this is the strangest and best answer in the passage. "Time cooks all beings in the great pot of days and nights, and the seasons are the ladle. That is the news."

The last question ​

The Yaksha is satisfied and offers to restore one brother.

Yudhishthira chooses Nakula.

The Yaksha is surprised. Bhima has the strength of ten thousand elephants. Arjuna is the greatest archer alive. You are at war with a superior enemy. So why choose the least useful brother?

Yudhishthira says: my father had two wives. I am Kunti's son and I am alive. Madri's sons are both dead. If only one can live, it should be one of hers, so that each of my father's wives has a living son.

He chooses justice over advantage, at the moment of maximum need, when no one would have blamed him for choosing Arjuna.

The Yaksha restores all four. He is Dharma himself, Yudhishthira's own father, and the test was the point.

what makes a person high-born?not birth, not learningconduct, and nothing elsethe greatest wonder?everyone watches others dieand expects to be the exceptionwhat is true happiness?living within your means,at home, having eaten simplywhere is the path?not in argument or scripture,which disagree — in what good people did
Four of the Yaksha's answers. Together they are the closest thing the Mahabharata has to a creed: character over birth, mortality taken seriously, sufficiency over accumulation, and example over doctrine.

The thirteenth year ​

They serve it in disguise at the court of Virata, king of Matsya, and the disguises are deliberately humiliating.

Yudhishthira becomes a courtier who teaches dice. The man whose gambling caused all of this spends a year as a professional dice player. The epic does this on purpose.

Bhima becomes a cook. Arjuna becomes a dance and music teacher in the women's quarters, living as a eunuch, which for the greatest warrior of the age is the most complete inversion available. Nakula and Sahadeva mind horses and cattle. Draupadi becomes a queen's maidservant, dressing hair — hers still loose.

They survive the year by being unrecognisable, which requires being genuinely humble rather than performing humility. The text notes that Bhima cooks well and Arjuna teaches well.

And then Draupadi is harassed. Kichaka, the queen's brother and the real power in the kingdom, pursues her. She goes to Yudhishthira and is told to endure it — the year is nearly done. She goes to Bhima instead, who kills Kichaka at night, in secret, in a way that looks like something supernatural.

The pattern of the dice hall, repeating. Draupadi is threatened; the righteous husband counsels patience for a rule's sake; the one who acts is the one who does not care about the rule. The epic is testing whether you learned anything from 3.9, and it has arranged the same scene with a different cast.

What to carry from this page ​

Use the forced pause. Sometimes life makes us stop, through an illness, the loss of a job, or a long wait. Each of those times is either preparation or it is thirteen wasted years. Arjuna went for weapons.

"Everybody dies and everybody plans as though they will not." Read that once a year. It is the most useful sentence in the epic and it is free.

Conduct, not birth. The Mahabharata says it at its most solemn moment, and it says it in a society organised on the opposite principle. Quote it when you need it.

And when you are choosing under pressure, notice whether you are choosing the useful thing or the fair thing, and notice how easily "useful" can be dressed as necessary. Yudhishthira had every reason to pick Arjuna and picked Nakula, and it is the single cleanest act by any Pandava in the entire book.

Next: 3.11. The exile ends, and the kingdom is refused. Krishna goes to Hastinapura himself to make the last attempt at peace.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet