Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

9.3 — The Six Darshanas, Mapped ​

Darshana means "view" or "seeing" — from the root drish, to see. The word for a philosophical system in India is not "doctrine" or "school of thought" but "a way of looking."

And that is a useful thing to know before the list, because it explains why the six are treated as complementary rather than as rivals. A tradition that calls its systems "views" is less likely to require you to pick one.

Orthodox and heterodox ​

The first division, and it is not about belief in God.

Astika — usually translated orthodox — means accepting the authority of the Vedas.

Nastika — heterodox — means not accepting it.

And the crucial point: this has nothing to do with theism. Samkhya is atheistic and orthodox. Early Mimamsa is effectively atheistic and orthodox. Buddhism and Jainism are heterodox and both have elaborate metaphysics.

The dividing line is textual authority, not God, and that is a distinctive feature of the Indian philosophical landscape.

There are six orthodox systems. There are also three heterodox ones, which are Buddhism (Part 6), Jainism and Charvaka (9.10, 9.11). Here heterodox means that they do not accept the authority of the Vedas.

The six, in pairs ​

They are traditionally given as three pairs. The pairing is not arbitrary. Each pair is a metaphysics, which is a view of what exists, together with a method.

Samkhya and Yoga ​

Samkhya — the oldest, and it is an analysis of what exists. Two ultimate categories: consciousness and matter. Atheistic in its classical form. 9.4.

Yoga — Patanjali's system. Accepts Samkhya's metaphysics almost entirely and supplies the practice. 9.5.

The pair: Samkhya says what the problem is, Yoga says what to do about it.

Nyaya and Vaisheshika ​

Nyaya — logic and epistemology. How do we know anything, what counts as valid reasoning, and what is a fallacy.

Vaisheshika — the analysis of what things are made of. An atomic theory.

The pair: Vaisheshika supplies the ontology, Nyaya supplies the method of establishing it. 9.6.

Mimamsa and Vedanta ​

Mimamsa — the interpretation of the ritual portion of the Vedas. How to read an instruction, and what makes an action obligatory. 9.7.

Vedanta — literally "the end of the Veda," meaning the Upanishads. The interpretation of the philosophical portion. 9.8 and 9.9.

The pair: two halves of one text, and two schools that ended up in deep disagreement about which half matters.

orthodox — accept Vedic authoritySamkhyawhat exists: two categoriesYoga — and what to doVaisheshikaatoms and categoriesNyaya — and how we knowMimamsathe ritual half, read strictlyVedanta — the philosophical halfheterodox — do notBuddhismno self, dependent arisingJainismnon-harm, many-sidednessCharvakamatter only, this life onlyThe dividing line is textual authority, not belief in God — Samkhya is atheistic and orthodox.
The nine systems. The orthodox six come in pairs, each pairing a metaphysics with its method. The line between orthodox and heterodox is acceptance of Vedic authority, which is why an atheistic system can sit on the orthodox side.

The question they are all answering ​

And this is what makes them a conversation rather than a list.

Every one of the nine systems is answering the same question, and the question is not "what is true."

It is: what is the cause of bondage, and how does it end?

Every school agrees that the ordinary human condition is one of being caught — in repetition, in suffering, in a cycle — and every school proposes a diagnosis and a route out.

Samkhya: you are caught because consciousness has mistaken itself for matter. Discrimination between the two frees you.

Yoga: the same, plus a graded practice for achieving the discrimination.

Nyaya: false knowledge causes attachment causes action causes rebirth. Correct knowledge, obtained by valid reasoning, breaks the chain at the first link.

Vaisheshika: understanding what things actually are removes the misapprehension.

Mimamsa: perform the prescribed actions correctly, without desire for their fruits. This is very close to the Gita's karma yoga (5.3), which is the path of acting well without clinging to the result.

Vedanta: you are caught by ignorance of what you actually are. Knowing "you are that" ends it (9.2, 9.8).

Buddhism: the grip causes it, and releasing the grip ends it (6.5).

Jainism: action accumulates a subtle matter that binds; austerity and non-harm remove it (9.11).

And Charvaka: you are not caught by anything, there is no cycle, this is the only life, and the whole framing is a fiction maintained by priests (9.10).

How the argument was conducted ​

Indian philosophy has one feature that is both unusual and admirable.

The standard format asked you to state your opponent's position first, and to state it fairly and completely. Only then could you answer it.

The purvapaksha — the prior position — is set out as well as its own proponents would state it, and frequently better. Then the refutation, then the conclusion.

Which means a great deal of what we know about lost schools comes from the works of their opponents, because the opponents stated their case properly. Charvaka's own texts are almost entirely lost and we know the system largely from the arguments against it (9.10).

This is a genuinely good intellectual norm and Volume VI's chapter on being your own devil's advocate is the modern version of the same discipline.

What each is best at ​

A practical map, because you will meet all six unevenly.

Samkhya: the clearest analysis of the difference between the observer and the observed. Read it if 5.5 interested you.

Yoga: the most usable practical system, and the one with the most direct modern descendants.

Nyaya: the most rigorous. This is India's logic, and it is real logic. It has a theory of inference. It has a theory of the valid means of knowledge. It has a catalogue of fallacies, which are common mistakes in reasoning. This catalogue stands comparison with anything produced elsewhere before the modern period.

Vaisheshika: mostly of historical interest, though the atomism is striking.

Mimamsa: the least appealing and the most surprising, because its theory of how to read a text and how obligation works is sophisticated and it is where the "act without desire for the fruit" idea largely comes from.

And Vedanta: the one that won, and which most people mean when they say Indian philosophy.

What to carry from this page ​

Darshana means a way of looking, not a doctrine. A tradition that names its systems that way is less likely to demand you pick one.

Orthodox means accepting textual authority, not believing in God. An atheistic system sits comfortably on the orthodox side.

All nine are answering one question — what causes the bondage and how does it end — which is why they can be compared at all.

State your opponent's case fairly and completely before you answer it. That was the required format. It is the reason we still have the arguments of schools whose own books are gone.

Next: 9.4 — the oldest system, which counts the components of existence and arrives at a conclusion that is both atheistic and profoundly strange.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet