Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

5.1 — The Setting: A Man Who Will Not Fight ​

Seven hundred verses, eighteen chapters, spoken between two armies while everybody waits.

It is the most read and most translated Indian text in the world. Before we read it, it helps to know what kind of book it is.

What it is, structurally ​

It sits inside the Mahabharata, in the sixth book. It sits at the moment described in 3.12. Arjuna asks to be driven into the space between the armies. He sees his family on both sides. Then he puts down his bow.

It is very probably an insertion (1.3, 4.1). The language, the philosophical vocabulary and the theological content place it later than the war narrative around it. The story of the war also works perfectly well without it. Most scholars hold this view. Some readers find it upsetting, because the Gita is sacred to them. But where the words came from does not change what they teach.

The Gita is not a report of a conversation. Nobody claims it was written down as it was spoken. It is a philosophical work, composed with enormous care. Its author placed it at the most extreme moment possible. A man is about to kill his own family. He has stopped, and he is asking what he should do.

The placement is part of the argument. The Gita is a teaching about how to act. It places that teaching at the hardest moment a person could face. If the teaching holds at this moment, it can hold anywhere. If it fails here, it is little more than a nice idea.

Why it is spoken to a soldier ​

The most common modern discomfort about the Gita: it is a spiritual text whose conclusion is "fight the war."

Many readers feel uneasy that a spiritual text ends by telling a man to fight a war. That unease deserves a real answer. The answer will help you read the whole Gita.

The question Arjuna asks is not "should there be a war." That question was answered over twenty years. In that time there were about fifteen chances to avoid war, and all of them failed (3.18). The armies are drawn up. Both sides have refused every settlement. The war has begun.

His question is: can I do the thing I am here to do, or will I be destroyed by doing it?

This is a very different question, and almost everybody meets it at some point in life. It is not is this the right cause. Usually you already know the answer, or the decision was made long ago. The real question is whether you can act at all when the action costs something you cannot bear. It is also whether you can live afterwards with having acted.

A doctor may have to decide to stop a treatment. A grown child may have to move a parent into a care home. A manager may have to make people redundant. A parent may have to let a child fail. A person may have to leave a marriage that has children in it. In every case the thinking is finished, and the action still feels impossible.

Arjuna stands in exactly this place, and the Gita is given for people in this place.

Arjuna's actual argument ​

Arjuna's reasons are good ones. The Gita does not weaken them. It lets him say every one of them fully before Krishna answers.

He says: if we win, we will have killed everyone we would have shared the victory with. True — 3.18 confirms every word.

He says the families will be destroyed and the social order will break down. True.

He says that killing his teachers and elders is a sin, whatever the provocation. Defensible.

He says he would rather be killed unarmed than do it. Sincere.

And then he says the sentence that gets him the answer: I do not know what is right. I am asking you as your student. Tell me.

Everything depends on that last step. He does not ask for reassurance. He does not ask for a strategy. He admits total confusion and asks to be taught. 3.12 already made this point. He is the only person on that field looking clearly at what is about to happen. Everybody else is protected from seeing it by a vow, a salary or a grievance.

What the answer is not ​

There are three things the Gita does not say to him. Each of these gaps teaches us something.

It does not say the war is just and he should feel good about it. Krishna never argues that the cause is righteous, that the Kauravas deserve it, or that Arjuna will enjoy the outcome. The moral case for the war is not made anywhere in the Gita.

It does not tell him to suppress the feeling. Nothing in it says he is weak for grieving or that he should stop caring.

And it does not promise a good result. The word for outcome — phala, fruit — appears constantly, and always in the context of not depending on it.

What the answer is, in one sentence ​

Do what is yours to do, at full commitment, and let go of the requirement that it turn out the way you want.

This is the whole teaching. The seven hundred verses explain three things. They explain why this is possible. They explain why it is not the same as indifference. They explain how to get there. Saying it takes eight seconds, but doing it takes a whole life.

It comes in three routes. The text presents them as suited to different people, and it does not rank them. The routes are action (5.3), knowledge (5.4) and devotion (5.7). They are not alternatives so much as three doors into the same room. Most people use more than one.

What the Gita assumes, stated plainly ​

Because you should know what you are agreeing to when you read it.

That there is something in you that is not the body and not the personality, and that it is not destroyed when the body is (5.2). This is a metaphysical claim and it is not proven.

That action is unavoidable. Nobody can not act; even sitting still is a choice with consequences. This one is straightforwardly true and it does a great deal of work.

That the anxiety attached to action comes from the demand for a specific result, not from the action itself. This is a psychological claim and it is largely correct, and Volume VI reaches it independently.

And that a life organised around duty performed without grasping is better than one organised around getting what you want. This is a value claim and you may accept or reject it.

The useful thing about the Gita is that the second and third assumptions carry most of the practical content, and you can take those without the first. Many people do, and the text is not damaged by it.

I cannot do this andI do not know what is rightkarma — do the workwithout clinging to the fruitjnana — see whatyou actually arebhakti — hand it overto something largeract fully, without needing the result
The structure of the argument. Three routes, presented as suited to different temperaments rather than ranked, all arriving at the same instruction.

How this Part will read it ​

Honestly, and in plain English, with the Sanskrit given where the word matters.

Every verse quoted will be translated as literally as English allows. Where the standard translation adds something the Sanskrit does not say, the page will point it out. The Gita has been used for a great many purposes. Colonial administrators, nationalists, pacifists and people justifying violence have all used it. 5.11 goes through the misuses.

The teaching sections are 5.3 to 5.9. The twenty verses worth carrying for life are 5.10.

And one thing to hold throughout. Arjuna's objection is never answered on its own terms. He says the family will be destroyed, and it is. He says the victory will be worthless, and it is. Krishna does not tell him he is wrong about any of it.

What he tells him is that being right about the consequences does not settle what you should do, and that is either the deepest thing in the book or the most alarming, and 5.11 takes that up properly.

Next: 5.2 gives the first teaching. It is delivered to a man sitting on the floor of a chariot, and it begins with what happens when you die.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet