Appearance
12.9 — What the Traditions Actually Agree On
The comfortable claim is that all religions are saying the same thing.
They are not, and 11.12 and 12.4 established the differences.
But something does overlap, and it is not nothing, and identifying it precisely is more useful than either the comfortable version or the dismissive one.
Where they do not agree
First, clearly, because the overlap is only interesting once the disagreements are on the table.
On God. One, personal (Judaism, Islam). One in three persons, incarnate (Christianity). One reality that you are (Advaita). Many, real (much of Hinduism, Shinto, Yoruba). None required (Buddhism, Jainism, Samkhya, Confucianism).
On what a person is. One view is that a person is a created soul. Another is that a person is an eternal self, identical with the ultimate (9.2). Another is that a person is a stream of processes, with no self at all (6.7). Another is that a person is a soul weighed down by physical karma (9.11).
On death. Resurrection and judgement. Rebirth until release. Reputation among the living (11.6). A shade in a dark house eating dust (11.8). Ceasing entirely (9.10).
On time. One view is that time is a line, with a beginning and an end. The other is that it is a circle that turns forever.
On the world. Created and good. An appearance that is not finally real (9.8). A battleground (12.5). Maintained daily against chaos (11.7).
These are not emphases. They are incompatible claims, and a person who says they all mean the same thing has not read them.
Where they do agree
And now the overlap, in five items.
One: the ethical core
This is the largest and most striking area of agreement, and it holds across traditions with nothing else in common.
Some version of the golden rule appears in essentially all of them.
Confucius: do not impose on others what you do not desire (12.6).
The Mahabharata says this is the sum of duty. Do not do to others what would cause you pain if it were done to you.
Hillel, asked to summarise the Torah while standing on one foot: what is hateful to you, do not do to your fellow; the rest is commentary.
Jesus: do to others as you would have them do to you.
The Buddha: one who, seeking happiness, harms others who also seek happiness, will not find it.
A hadith: none of you truly believes until he wishes for his brother what he wishes for himself.
Beyond the rule itself, there is a shared set of teachings. All of them forbid killing, theft, deception and betrayal. All of them require care for the poor. All of them teach honour for parents. All of them teach hospitality to strangers.
Every single tradition in this Part has all of these.
We should state carefully what this agreement means. It does not prove a divine source. It does not prove that all traditions are one religion. A better explanation is that these are the rules any group of people must have in order to be a group at all. Traditions that lacked them did not last.
This explanation looks only at how people live together. It does not make the agreement smaller. It makes it more impressive. Many independent traditions, over thousands of years, arrived at the same short list. They arrived there because it is what actually works.
Two: the diagnosis
Every tradition says something is wrong with the ordinary human condition.
And the diagnoses rhyme.
Something in the way you want things is the problem.
Buddhism: the grip (6.5). Hinduism: attachment and the six enemies (8.5). Christianity: sin, in the sense of a disordered will turned in on itself — Augustine's account (10.7). Islam: forgetfulness of God and the commanding self. Jainism: the accumulation from action. Stoicism, which is not a religion and belongs here anyway: treating what is not up to you as though it were (10.5).
Different vocabularies, and the finger is pointing at approximately the same thing.
Three: it is workable
No tradition says the condition is permanent and untreatable.
Every one of them offers a route: practice, grace, discipline, devotion, insight, submission, or law.
And every one of them says it takes a long time and requires something from you.
Four: the practices
From 12.7, and this is the most concrete overlap.
Every tradition shares a set of practices. It has repeated ritual. It has some form of fasting or voluntary going-without. It has communal gathering. It has a set-aside period. It has a practice of attention or prayer. It has pilgrimage or a sacred place.
They have these in incompatible theological frameworks, which strongly suggests the practices do something independent of the theology.
Five: and the mystics
The most interesting item on the list, and 12.4 flagged it.
The mystics of every tradition resemble each other far more than the mainstreams do.
Compare: Meister Eckhart on the ground of the soul being identical with the ground of God. Rumi and the Sufi poets on annihilation of the self in the beloved. The Kabbalists on ein sof, the limitless. Shankara on tat tvam asi (9.8). The Buddhist accounts of dissolution. Laozi's dao that cannot be spoken.
They report: the collapse of the distinction between subject and object; that language fails; that the ultimate is not a thing among things and cannot be described positively; and that the experience is more real than ordinary experience rather than less.
And they were regarded with suspicion by their own institutions, consistently. Eckhart was tried for heresy. Al-Hallaj was executed. Several Kabbalistic movements were suppressed.
Two readings, and this book will state both.
The generous one: they are all describing the same thing, and the doctrinal differences are at the level of interpretation rather than experience.
And the deflationary one: the human nervous system has a small number of available extreme states, and people in them report similar things because the reports are constrained by the equipment rather than by the object. 15.4 covers what is actually known.
Both readings explain the convergence. Neither is established. What is established is the convergence itself, and it is a real fact that needs an explanation.
What this means practically
Three things.
Where the traditions agree, take it seriously. A conclusion reached independently by Confucian China, Vedic India, Hebrew Palestine and Buddhist Magadha, over two thousand years, on the basis of completely different metaphysics, is about as well-tested as a claim about human beings can be.
Where they disagree, do not paper over it. Whether there is a self is not an emphasis. A dialogue that requires everybody to pretend the differences are superficial is not respectful of any of them, and 12.5 flagged the same problem with the Bahá'í framework.
The two halves are quite different. The traditions agree on how people should treat each other. They disagree on what is ultimately real. So the practical half is well supported, and the half about ultimate reality is the one people dispute.
This is the most useful conclusion in this Part. Suppose you are looking for guidance on how to live. The traditions agree remarkably well, and you can act on what they say. Suppose you are looking for an answer about what is ultimately real. Here they contradict each other, and you will have to decide for yourself.
What to carry from this page
The golden rule, in some form, in all of them. Independently, and the naturalistic explanation makes it more impressive rather than less.
Something about the way you want things is the problem. Six traditions, six vocabularies, one finger pointing.
The practices are shared and the theologies are not, which suggests the practices work independently of the beliefs.
The mystics converge and were all suspect to their own institutions.
And the agreement is on conduct and the disagreement is on metaphysics. Which is exactly the opposite of how these traditions are usually argued about.
Next: Part 13 takes up the practical half. It asks a question the traditions mostly take for granted. How do you actually decide what is right, when the rules conflict and nobody is going to tell you?