Appearance
9.11 — Jainism and Sikhism
Two complete traditions, separated by two thousand years, and both begin by refusing something.
Jainism
The tradition holds a line of twenty-four tirthankaras — "ford-makers," those who make a crossing possible. The twenty-third, Parshvanatha, is probably historical, around the ninth or eighth century BCE. **The twenty-fourth is Mahavira, a contemporary of the Buddha, in the same region, in the same intellectual ferment (6.1).
He was born into a clan republic family, left at thirty, practised extreme austerity for twelve years, and taught for thirty. The parallels with the Buddha are exact except for one thing: where the Buddha rejected austerity and found the middle way (6.3), Mahavira went further into it.
The core claims
Every living thing has a soul — jiva — and the souls are countless and eternal. **Not only animals: plants, and — distinctively — beings in earth, water, fire and air.
Karma is physical. This is Jainism's most distinctive doctrine. Karma is not a moral account. It is a fine material substance that sticks to the soul because of action and weighs it down. It is a little like fine dust settling on a clean cloth.
Which produces a very specific practice. You must stop new karma sticking, and burn off what has already stuck. Stopping is done by restraint; burning off is done by austerity.
And liberation is the soul, freed of all accumulated matter, rising to the top of the universe and remaining there in omniscient bliss.
Ahimsa, taken all the way
Every tradition in this volume teaches non-harm. Jainism is the one that did not stop.
Strict vegetarianism, and beyond it: no root vegetables, because uprooting a plant kills it and disturbs the organisms in the soil.
Monks sweep the path in front of them so as not to tread on insects. They filter water. Some wear a cloth over the mouth to avoid inhaling small creatures.
Jain rules forbid occupations that involve harm. This is why Jain communities historically concentrated in trade, finance and, later, the professions. A whole community's economic life was shaped by an ethical rule.
There is also the practice of sallekhana. It is voluntary fasting to death, undertaken by the very old or the terminally ill under strict conditions, as a final act of non-attachment. It is still contested in India, both legally and ethically. The tradition defends it as different from suicide, because of the state of mind involved.
Anekantavada — the doctrine that deserves to be famous
And Jainism's real philosophical contribution, which is under-known and excellent.
Anekantavada — "the doctrine of non-one-sidedness." Reality is complex. Any single statement about it captures only one aspect. In plain words, the truth has many sides, and each statement shows only one of them.
The image is the blind men and the elephant. It was a Jain teaching story before it was anything else. One man touches the trunk and says it is a snake. One touches the ear and says it is a fan. One touches the leg and says it is a pillar. Each one reports accurately. Each one is wrong to think he has the whole.
The idea is developed into a formal system called syadvada, the doctrine of "in some respect." Every statement begins with syat, which means "in a certain sense." Seven combinations of saying yes, saying no, and saying that it cannot be put into words are worked out.
The consequence is a built-in intellectual humility that is unique among these systems. Jain philosophers did not say the other schools were wrong; they said each had captured an aspect and mistaken it for the whole.
This is a better habit of mind than any other in this Part. You can adopt it on its own, apart from everything else Jainism holds.
Sikhism
Founded by Guru Nanak, born 1469 in what is now Pakistan, in a region where Hindu and Islamic traditions had been in contact — and conflict — for centuries.
The founding statement, after a formative experience in his thirties, is reported as: there is no Hindu, there is no Muslim.
Not that both are the same. That neither category is what matters.
The core
Ik Onkar — "one reality." The opening words of the scripture and the tradition's central affirmation. One God, without form, not incarnate, not represented by images.
Three practices, stated as a formula that has held for five centuries.
Naam japna — remembrance of the divine name. A continuous inward practice, available while working.
Kirat karni — honest labour. You work. There is no monastic option and no renunciation. This is a distinctive position, and it is a deliberate rejection of the way of the ascetic, who gives up worldly life.
Vand chakna — sharing what you earn.
One institution shows all three together. It is langar, the free community kitchen. In it, everybody sits on the floor in rows and eats the same food. Caste, religion, wealth and gender make no difference.
Nanak established this at the founding, explicitly to break the caste rules of commensality. Those are the rules about who may eat with whom. They were the everyday way the caste system worked. It is still run, daily, at every gurdwara in the world, and the one at Amritsar feeds tens of thousands of people a day.
An institution designed in the sixteenth century to attack a social structure, still operating at scale, and open to anybody who walks in.
The ten Gurus and the scripture
Nine successors, and each added something.
The third Guru made the langar compulsory before anyone could have an audience with him. Tradition says this included the Mughal emperor Akbar.
The fifth, Arjan, compiled the scripture and was executed by the Mughal state in 1606.
The ninth, Tegh Bahadur, was executed in 1675. The tradition records that he died defending the right of Kashmiri Hindus to practise their own religion. This is an unusual thing to be martyred for.
The tenth, Gobind Singh, founded the Khalsa in 1699, a community with a distinct identity and discipline, and then ended the line of human Gurus — declaring the scripture itself the eternal Guru.
The Guru Granth Sahib is therefore not a book about the Guru; it is the Guru, and it is treated accordingly.
Its contents matter a great deal. It includes verses by Hindu and Muslim devotional poets, such as Kabir, Ravidas the leatherworker, Namdev, and the Sufi Farid. They stand alongside the Gurus' own verses. This scripture includes voices from outside its own tradition, and from the lowest castes, and it does so by design.
What these two share
The two traditions look nothing alike, so it helps to name what they share.
Both begin by refusing a category. Jainism refuses the idea that some living things do not count. Sikhism refuses the idea that the religious categories are what matter.
Both put the refusal into a daily physical practice rather than a doctrine. Sweeping the path; sitting on the floor to eat. In both cases a bodily habit that makes the principle unavoidable, which is far more effective than any amount of assent.
And both took a cost for it. The Jain economic profile was shaped by an ethical rule accepted over centuries. Two Sikh Gurus were executed.
What to carry from this page
Anekantavada: every statement captures an aspect, and the error is mistaking the aspect for the whole. The best intellectual posture in this Part and it can be adopted on its own.
Karma treated as physical produces a completely different practice. This reminds us that a teaching's practical results follow from its exact form, not from its general shape.
Honest labour, remembrance, and sharing — with no monastic option. A tradition that deliberately closed the escape route to renunciation.
And an institution designed to break a social rule, still operating five hundred years later, feeding anybody who walks in. The langar is the most successful piece of applied ethics in this volume, and it works because it is a physical arrangement rather than a principle.
Next: Part 10 crosses to the other tradition. That tradition started by asking what things are made of. It reached the same questions from the opposite end.