Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

13.5 — Care, Justice, and the Ethics of Relationships ​

The three theories in 13.2 to 13.4 have something in common that is easy to miss.

They are all built for the encounter between strangers.

Consequentialism counts everybody equally, which means nobody in particular. Deontology asks what any rational agent owes any other. Even virtue ethics is about your dispositions rather than about specific relationships.

And almost none of your moral life happens between strangers.

It happens with your parents, your partner, your children, your friends, your colleagues and the people you have known for twenty years. In these relationships the obligations are specific. They are unequal. You did not choose them. They never stop.

The care ethics correction ​

This criticism of older moral theories grew out of developmental psychology in the 1980s. That field studies how children and adults grow in the way they think and feel.

Carol Gilligan noticed that studies of moral development were scoring people on a scale that rewarded abstract-principle reasoning, and that people who reasoned in terms of relationships and consequences for specific people scored lower.

Her argument: that is not a lower stage of reasoning. It is a different one, and the scale had built in a preference.

And the position that developed from it — care ethics — makes four claims, and all four are worth having independently of the original research, some of which is contested.

One: relationships are primary, not derivative ​

The standard theories treat you as an independent agent who then enters relationships.

Care ethics reverses it: you are constituted by relationships. You did not choose your parents, your language, your body or your first ten years, and you were entirely dependent for a long time and will be again.

Which means the picture of a self-sufficient rational agent choosing his obligations is not a description of a human being at any point in their life.

Two: dependency is normal, not exceptional ​

Everybody is completely dependent at the start and most people are at the end, and many people are in between.

A moral theory built around competent adults dealing with competent adults leaves out most of human experience. It has also undervalued the work of caring for people who depend on others. Historically, this work has mostly been done by women. In every framework it has stayed invisible.

Three: attention is a moral act ​

And this is the most practically useful claim.

Before you can act well towards somebody, you have to perceive their situation accurately, and that perception is not automatic.

Iris Murdoch made this the centre of her ethics: the moral work happens in the looking, not in the choosing. By the time you are deciding, most of the work is done, because what you are choosing between was determined by what you saw.

Her example: a woman who thinks her daughter-in-law is vulgar and common, and who — over time, deliberately, without any external change — comes to see her as fresh and spontaneous instead. **Nothing happens externally. **No decision is made. And something moral has occurred.

Which is a genuine correction to all three standard theories: none of them has a place for the work of seeing somebody accurately.

Four: the response should fit the person ​

Justice-based ethics aims at treating like cases alike.

Care ethics points out that in a relationship, the whole point is that this person is not like other cases. They have a history with you. They have specific needs. You know their situation in detail.

Treating your friend by a general rule about friends is not better ethics; it is worse.

The tension with justice ​

And it is real, and it should not be dissolved.

Impartiality is the foundation of justice. **A judge who favours a friend is corrupt. A hiring decision made on relationships rather than merit is unjust. Bentham's "each to count for one" is what made utilitarianism a reforming force (13.2).

And partiality is the foundation of every relationship you have. A parent who allocated their attention impartially across all children in the world would be a monster.

So: which?

And the answer that holds is a division of domains.

Impartiality governs the exercise of public power and the allocation of things people have a claim on. Courts, hiring, medicine, votes, public money. In these contexts, favouring your own is corruption.

Partiality governs personal relationships. In these contexts, refusing to favour your own is a failure.

And the moral errors are the boundary violations, in both directions.

Using a public position for your people is nepotism.

And treating your family with the detachment appropriate to a public role is the other failure, and it is less discussed and it is real.

What relationships actually require ​

And the practical content, because this is the chapter that is closest to a life.

Attention, specifically. Not availability — attention. **Knowing what is going on with somebody, currently, in detail. Which requires asking and requires remembering the answer.

Reliability over intensity. Volume VI's relationship research is unambiguous on this: what predicts survival is the accumulation of small reliable responses, not the occasional large gesture.

Repair. All relationships have ruptures. The distinguishing feature of the ones that last is not fewer ruptures but faster repair, and the mechanism is somebody moving first.

Not keeping score. 7.3's point about the ledger: a relationship in which contributions are being tracked has already changed into a different kind of arrangement, and everybody can feel it.

And accepting asymmetry. Care is frequently unequal and will be unequal in different directions at different times. A person who requires the account to balance at every moment cannot care for anybody who is ill, small, old or in trouble.

The obligations you did not choose ​

And the hardest case in this chapter.

You did not choose your parents.

Every tradition in this volume says you owe them something. Confucianism calls it xiao (12.6). It is one of the Ten Commandments. The Yaksha answers that a mother is heavier than the earth (3.10).

And some parents were harmful.

This book's position, stated because the traditions mostly do not.

The obligation is real and it is not unlimited. You owe your parents something for having raised you, and what you owe is not everything, and it does not include continuing to be harmed.

The frameworks help here. Care ethics says the response should fit the actual relationship rather than a general rule about parents. Kant's second formulation says you may not be used merely as a means, and that applies to family. Virtue ethics asks what a person of good character would do. Generally, such a person meets the obligation at a level they can sustain. They also set a boundary. They do not pretend that the debt does not exist, and they do not pretend that it has no limit.

Volume VI's chapters on difficult family relationships are the practical treatment.

What to carry from this page ​

You are constituted by relationships rather than entering them as a finished agent. Every theory that starts from an independent chooser has skipped the first twenty years.

The moral work happens in the looking. By the time you are deciding, what you saw has already determined the options.

Be impartial in public power and partial in personal relationships. The errors happen when the boundary is crossed in either direction.

Repair is the distinguishing feature, not the absence of rupture — and somebody has to move first.

An obligation you did not choose is real. It is also not unlimited. Both halves are true together.

Next: 13.6 — five hard cases, worked, and none of them resolve cleanly.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet