Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

10.10 — Kierkegaard, Nietzsche and the Existentialists ​

It began as a reaction, and the target was Hegel. Hegel built an enormous system. It claimed to show that history is the rational unfolding of Spirit towards freedom. It also claimed that everything, including your own life, has its place in it.

And the objection is simple: I am not a place in a system. I am a specific person who has to decide what to do on Tuesday and who is going to die.

Kierkegaard ​

Danish, 1813 to 1855, and the first person to make that objection systematically.

He wrote under a series of pseudonyms, each presenting a position he did not necessarily hold, so the reader would have to decide rather than be told.

The three stages ​

Three ways of living, and each collapses into the next.

The aesthetic. Life organised around interest — pleasure, novelty, avoiding boredom. **The person here is not necessarily hedonistic; they may be sophisticated and refined. What defines them is that they are a spectator of their own life, keeping options open, committing to nothing.

And it collapses into despair, because nothing accumulates. A life of interesting moments with no commitment has no shape.

The ethical. This stage is about commitment. It means marriage, work, duty and the acceptance of obligations. You become a specific person by binding yourself to something.

This stage is genuinely better, and Kierkegaard says so. It also fails. You will not meet the standard, and the ethical life gives you no way to deal with your own failure.

And the religious. A relationship with the absolute, entered by a leap that reason cannot justify.

The leap ​

And this is his most famous idea, and it is regularly softened into something harmless.

Faith is not believing things without evidence in a comfortable way. It is a commitment made in objective uncertainty, without a guarantee, that you cannot justify to anybody, and that you are responsible for.

His example is Abraham, told to sacrifice his son. From the ethical standpoint, Abraham is a man preparing to murder a child, and no argument makes that acceptable. Kierkegaard does not resolve this. He calls it the teleological suspension of the ethical, which means setting the ethical aside for a higher call. He says it cannot be understood from outside. Abraham cannot explain himself to anybody. This is what makes it faith rather than reasoning.

Whether you find this profound or alarming, the structural point survives: some commitments cannot be justified from outside them, and making one is a decision rather than a conclusion.

Anxiety ​

And his best psychological observation, which is genuinely original.

Anxiety is different from fear. Fear has an object — you fear the dog. Anxiety has none.

And what produces it is freedom. Standing at a cliff edge, you are afraid of falling and you are also anxious about the fact that you could jump. The dizziness is not the height; it is the possibility.

He calls it "the dizziness of freedom," and it is one of the most accurate descriptions of the state anybody has produced.

Nietzsche ​

1844 to 1900, German, a professor of classics at twenty-four, in poor health for most of his life, who collapsed into insanity at forty-four and never recovered.

He wrote in aphorisms and is quoted more and misread more than anybody in this Part.

God is dead ​

The line, and it is almost always taken backwards.

It is not a triumphant announcement of atheism. In the passage where the line appears, a madman runs into a marketplace with a lantern in daylight. He cries out for God. The people there do not believe, and they laugh at him.

And he tells them: we have killed him, and we do not understand what we have done. He asks who gave us the sponge to wipe away the horizon, whether we are not plunging continually, and whether it is not now colder.

Then he says: "I have come too early. This deed is still more distant from them than the most distant stars — and yet they have done it themselves."

The claim is diagnostic. The framework that grounded European morality no longer functions, most people have not noticed, and the consequences are coming. He predicted a century of enormous convulsions and he was right.

The problem, and his answer ​

If the ground of values is gone, either you invent new ones or you accept that there are none.

Nihilism is the second, and Nietzsche regards it as the danger rather than the conclusion.

His answer is the Übermensch — usually "overman" or "superman" — a person who creates values rather than receiving them. And it is deliberately underspecified; he does not give a description, and every attempt to make it concrete has been a distortion.

And the will to power. Not the desire to dominate other people, which is the standard misreading. A drive towards growth, mastery, the overcoming of resistance — including of oneself. The artist finishing a difficult work is exercising it.

Master and slave morality ​

His most inflammatory analysis, and it needs care.

He distinguishes two ways values arise.

Master morality begins with the strong. They call good whatever they are, which is noble, powerful and capable. They call bad whatever lacks those things.

Slave morality: those who are dominated cannot win, so they redefine. What the strong have becomes evil; what the weak have — humility, patience, meekness, restraint — becomes good.

And its engine is ressentiment, a resentment that cannot act and so becomes creative, producing a moral system in which the powerless are righteous.

Nietzsche's claim is that European morality is slave morality that won. He says it works to make weakness admirable and strength shameful.

Three honest observations.

The analysis is genuinely penetrating as a description of a psychological mechanism. Everybody has met a person whose moral positions are precisely calibrated to condemn what they cannot have, and 8.9's envy is the same phenomenon.

Nietzsche is not arguing that cruelty is good. He despised brutality and antisemitism. He broke with Wagner partly over it. He also wrote against German nationalism in plain words.

And it was catastrophically misused. His sister, who was an antisemite and a Nazi sympathiser, controlled his papers after his collapse and edited them to serve that purpose. The association is largely her work, and the texts do not support it.

Eternal recurrence ​

And the test he proposes, which is the most useful thing he wrote.

Suppose a demon told you that you must live this life again and again, innumerable times. Nothing new would be in it. Every pain, every joy and every thought would come back in the same order, forever.

Would you throw yourself down and curse him, or would you say: you are a god, and never have I heard anything more divine?

It is not a metaphysical claim. It is a test. Amor fati — love of fate — is his term for passing it.

You can ask the question about one ordinary week. Would I take this week again, unchanged, forever?

A photographic portrait of a nineteenth-century man with a large moustache, seated and looking away from the camera
Nietzsche in 1882, at thirty-eight. He collapsed six years later and never recovered; his sister then controlled his papers and edited them towards a politics he had explicitly attacked. Image: Wikimedia Commons.

The existentialists ​

And the twentieth-century inheritors.

Sartre's formula: existence precedes essence.

A paper knife has an essence before it exists — somebody designed it for cutting. A human being does not. You exist first, and what you are is produced by what you do.

Therefore: you are condemned to be free. There is no human nature that determines you, no God who assigned you a purpose, and no excuse. You are entirely responsible for what you become.

The name for this dodge is bad faith. It means pretending that your role, your circumstances or your nature made you do it. His example is a waiter who plays the part of a waiter with slightly too much care. He is hiding from the fact that he chose the job and could stop.

Simone de Beauvoir applied this idea and did the more lasting work. She wrote "One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman". She meant that a social role presented as nature is really something people built. This claim founded modern feminist theory (Volume VIII).

And Camus, who is the most useful of them.

The absurd is the collision between a human demand for meaning and a universe that does not supply one.

Three responses. The first is suicide, which he rejects. The second is a leap to religious faith, which he calls philosophical suicide. The third is revolt, which means living fully in the confrontation without looking for any higher appeal.

His image is Sisyphus, condemned to roll a boulder up a hill forever and watch it roll down. And his conclusion: the struggle itself is enough to fill a man's heart. One must imagine Sisyphus happy.

11.4 takes Sisyphus properly.

What to carry from this page ​

Anxiety is the dizziness of freedom. It has no object because its object is the possibility of your own choosing.

"God is dead" is a diagnosis and a warning, not a celebration, and the passage has a madman in it whom nobody understands.

Watch for values calibrated exactly to condemn what somebody cannot have. The mechanism is real, whatever you think of Nietzsche.

Would you take this week again, unchanged, forever? The best single question in this Part.

And existence precedes essence: nothing determines what you are except what you do. Which is either liberating or terrifying and is generally both.

Next: 10.11 — where the argument stands now, and the one that is still completely open.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet