Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

7.3 — Why He Is Bholenath, and Why That Matters ​

Bhola in Hindi means simple, innocent, guileless, easily fooled. Nath means lord.

"The simple lord." "The innocent one."

It is an affectionate name and it is very slightly cheeky, and it is applied to the god who destroys the universe. Understanding why is the most practically important thing in this Part.

The reputation ​

Shiva is famous for being easy.

The offerings are nothing. Water. A few leaves of the bilva tree, which grows wild. Milk, if you have it. No expensive ritual, no elaborate procedure, no specialist required. A person with nothing can worship him fully.

Compare what the Vedic sacrificial system required (4.4). It needed trained priests, precise procedure, enormous quantities of material, and days of preparation. People at the time saw this contrast clearly.

And the stories say he grants what is asked, quickly, and often unwisely.

The problem with being easy ​

Because the Puranas are entirely aware that this is a flaw, and they say so repeatedly.

He grants boons to people who should not have them. A boon is a gift or favour from a god. Ravana is the clearest case. He was a devotee of Shiva, granted enormous power, and he used it exactly as you would expect (2.14). Many Puranic stories tell of a demon who obtains a devastating boon from Shiva through devotion. Someone else then has to deal with the demon, usually Vishnu.

The most famous is Bhasmasura, who asks for the power to turn to ash anyone whose head he touches, receives it, and immediately tries it on Shiva — who has to run. He is dealt with by a trick.

The tradition is laughing at him, and it is affectionate laughter.

But the observation underneath is serious: he does not evaluate. He responds to sincerity and not to worthiness, and the stories show exactly what that costs.

Why the tradition kept it as a virtue anyway ​

There is a thoughtful reason behind this, and it is not naive.

A god who judges who is worthy is a god with an entry requirement. Entry requirements have to be run by people, and people have to decide who passes.

The moment access to the divine depends on being deserving, somebody has to decide who is deserving. In every society that has ever existed, that decision has been made along lines of birth, wealth, gender and status. The qualification becomes a hierarchy, and the hierarchy becomes a profession. First the test turns into a ranking of people. Then the ranking turns into a job that people hold.

Bholenath is the refusal of that. He is unevaluating on purpose, and the cost — that unworthy people get power — is accepted openly as the price of a door that cannot be gatekept.

And this is exactly the same move as the Gita's leaf (5.7) and the Buddha's ordination of a barber ahead of nobles (6.10) and Rama eating Shabari's berries (2.10). Four independent points in this volume where a tradition makes access unconditional and pays the cost.

Guileless, not stupid ​

And now the precision that makes the name worth having.

Bhola does not mean unintelligent. He is the Adiyogi, the source of the whole contemplative tradition (7.2), and the Puranas show him outwitting people regularly.

It means without calculation.

He does not manage his position. He does not weigh what a favour will cost him. He does not check whether the person asking is useful, connected, or likely to reflect well on him. He responds to what is in front of him.

This is a specific and rare human quality. We name it carefully, because it is so easily confused with foolishness.

Compare the alternative. A person who calculates every interaction is behaving rationally. Such a person asks what this will cost, what they will get, how it looks, and whether you are worth their time. They are also exhausting to be near and impossible to trust. Everybody can feel it, and nobody can prove it.

The guileless person is frequently taken advantage of. They are also the only kind of person anybody actually relaxes around.

The tradition judges that this trade is worth making. The trade is being taken advantage of at times, in return for being someone others can relax around. The tradition made that judgement about God as well.

The hardest to frighten and the easiest to please ​

And the two facts are the same fact, which is the chapter's real point.

Why is Shiva easy to please? Because there is nothing you can offer him that he wants and nothing you can threaten him with.

He owns nothing. He lives on a mountain, wears ash, and eats what is given. You cannot bribe him because he has no use for anything. You cannot threaten him because he has nothing to lose. The cremation ground is where he lives, and death is his own principle (7.1).

And a person with nothing to protect has nothing to calculate about. Which is why he can afford to be guileless.

The generosity and the fearlessness come out of the same emptiness, and this is the single most transferable observation in Part 7.

Look at it from the other side. Most people cannot be guileless because they have a great deal to protect. They have a position, a reputation, an income and a self-image. Every one of those makes us weigh each interaction for risk. The calculation is not a character flaw. It is a sensible response to having something at stake.

Which means the way to become less calculating is not to try to be more generous. It is to have less at stake, and 4.3 reached exactly this conclusion about Krishna's lightness by a different road.

What this looks like in a person ​

Concretely, because "be guileless" is useless as an instruction.

They give the benefit of the doubt by default. They are sometimes wrong, it costs them, and they carry on doing it. They are not naive. They have decided that the cost of being occasionally exploited is lower than the cost of being permanently suspicious.

They do not keep score. The mental ledger of who owes what is simply absent, and being near someone who has one is exhausting in a way people rarely name.

They are the same with everybody, which is 2.2's line about Rama and 4.2's about Krishna, and it is the most reliable single indicator of the quality.

They are hard to insult, because an insult needs a self-image to land on.

They are not pushovers. This is the part people often get wrong. Shiva is guileless, and he is the most dangerous figure in the pantheon. Guilelessness is not weakness. It is the absence of calculation. It fits well with saying no, with anger, and with force. 7.5 shows him at his most destructive.

The practice ​

One thing, and it is small.

Pick one interaction this week where you would normally calculate what this will cost, what you will get, and how it will look, and do not. Just respond to what is in front of you.

Notice two things afterwards. What it actually cost, which is almost always less than the calculation predicted. And what it felt like, which is the part worth having, because the calculating is itself a low-grade unpleasantness that people stop noticing because it never stops.

What to carry from this page ​

Bhola means without calculation, not without intelligence.

Unconditional access has a real cost — Ravana got his boon — and the tradition pays it deliberately, because the alternative is a door administered by people, and that door is never open to everybody.

The generosity and the fearlessness are the same thing. A person with nothing to protect has nothing to calculate about, which means the route to being less calculating is having less at stake, not trying harder to be kind.

And a person who keeps no ledger is the only kind anybody relaxes around. That is worth more than what the ledger protects.

Next: 7.4 — the story that this book thinks is the most useful in the whole of Indian mythology: a god who drank a poison nobody else would touch and did not swallow it.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet