Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

12.8 — Where Religion Has Done Harm, Honestly ​

A book that presents seven Parts of religious material and then declines to write this chapter is not being respectful. It is being dishonest.

So: the record, stated plainly, and then the harder question of what the mechanism actually is.

The record ​

Violence between traditions ​

The Crusades. Several centuries of campaigns, with the sack of Jerusalem in 1099 and the sack of Christian Constantinople by a Christian army in 1204 among the worst episodes.

There were also the European wars of religion. The Thirty Years' War killed a very large share of the people in parts of Germany. Estimates vary widely, but nobody doubts the devastation.

Partition. The division of India in 1947 produced communal violence that killed somewhere between several hundred thousand and two million people and displaced perhaps fifteen million. Volume VIII covers the causes, which were political as well as religious.

And the continuing pattern. Communal riots, sectarian conflict, and violence in which religious identity is the marker of the target.

Violence within traditions ​

The Inquisitions put people on trial for departing from official doctrine. They used judicial torture and execution.

Movements that the authorities called heretical were persecuted. Some of these groups were wiped out entirely, as whole populations.

Sunni-Shia conflict, from the seventh century to the present.

And the witch trials. Tens of thousands of people executed across Europe and colonial America over roughly three centuries, overwhelmingly women, on charges that were not possible to defend against.

Persecution of minorities ​

Jewish communities in Christian Europe were mistreated over a thousand years. They suffered expulsions, forced conversions, ghettos and massacres. They were also accused of ritual murder, a charge that was invented and repeated for centuries. The worst point came in a modern industrial state, which murdered six million people.

The forced conversion and destruction of indigenous religions in the Americas, Africa, Australia and the Pacific, frequently accompanied by the removal of children from families.

And current persecutions, including of Bahá'ís in Iran (12.5), of religious minorities in several states, and of people who leave a religion in jurisdictions where apostasy is a criminal offence.

Harm inside communities ​

The concealment of child sexual abuse by religious institutions, across multiple traditions, over decades, in which the institution's reputation was protected and the children were not. The scale of this and the length of the concealment are now documented in official inquiries in several countries.

Caste (12.2), and the theological justification supplied for it.

The subordination of women is another harm. They were denied legal rights. They were kept out of education and religious office. Their movement and marriage were controlled. Scripture was used to justify this in every one of the traditions in this Part.

And the treatment of gay people, which in several traditions has ranged from exclusion to criminalisation to execution, and continues.

The persecution of scientific claims also belongs here. It was smaller than the popular version suggests. Galileo is the famous case. The reality is more complicated than the legend, and Volume VIII covers it.

What the mechanism actually is ​

Now the harder question, because "religion causes violence" is too crude to be useful and "religion is never the real cause" is a defensive evasion.

Four mechanisms, and they are separable.

One: certainty about unfalsifiable claims ​

A dispute about a fact can be settled by evidence.

A dispute about a claim that no evidence can touch cannot be settled at all, and if both sides regard it as maximally important, there is no procedure available except force.

This is the mechanism most specific to religion, and it is why doctrinal disputes have been so bitter and why 6.13's no closed fist and 12.9's observations about the mystics matter.

Two: the strong boundary ​

From 12.1: the costly practice that produces trust inside the group is the same thing that produces a hard outside.

The mechanism that makes a religious community unusually cooperative and unusually generous internally is the mechanism that makes it capable of treating outsiders as a different category.

This is not unique to religion. Nationalism, ideology and ethnicity do the same thing. The twentieth century's largest atrocities were committed by states that were openly non-religious. This does not excuse religion. It shows that the habit of drawing a hard boundary is human, and not only religious. Religion is one of the strongest ways it shows itself.

Three: the absence of correction ​

An institution that claims divine authority for its decisions has taken away the way it could be told it is wrong. Nobody can easily correct a decision that is said to come from God.

And this is where the concealment of abuse comes from. Not from doctrine — no tradition teaches it — but from an institution whose reputation was treated as sacred and whose internal authority could not be challenged from outside or below.

The general form: any institution with authority and no external accountability produces this, and religious institutions have been unusually good at establishing exactly that condition.

Four: use by power ​

And the most common one.

Much of what is called religious violence is really political violence. It uses religious identity to mark who is on which side. Partition, the conflict in Northern Ireland, and many communal riots are explained better by land, power and resources than by theology. Political leaders who saw an opening also played a part. In each case the religious identity was real, and people used it.

Which does not clear religion. A thing that can be used this reliably as a mobilising identity is contributing something, and the contribution is that it supplies an unquestionable justification and a ready-made in-group.

What the traditions have said themselves ​

And this belongs here, because it is part of the record.

Ashoka's edict, third century BCE: one should not honour only one's own religion and condemn the religions of others, but should honour others' religions for this or that reason. Carved in rock, by an emperor, over two thousand years ago.

The Quran: there is no compulsion in religion.

The Rig Veda: truth is one, the wise call it by many names.

Every tradition also has its own critics inside it. There were prophets who spoke against empty ritual. There were mystics who ignored the boundaries. There were reformers. There were people burned by their own institutions for saying so.

The resources for the criticism are inside the traditions. They were available and were overruled, which is 3.9's room full of good men at civilisational scale.

The honest balance ​

And this book will state it rather than dodging it.

Religious institutions have also built hospitals, universities, orphanages and famine relief, at enormous scale and for a very long time, in periods when nobody else was doing it.

They have produced most of the world's art, music and architecture before the modern period.

They have supplied the ethical words that were used against slavery, against colonial rule and for civil rights. Gandhi, King and the abolitionists all used them. Each of them argued from inside their own tradition. They were speaking to people who stood inside the same tradition and disagreed.

And they supply, daily, the consolation that 12.1 identified as the function nothing has replaced.

Both columns are real and neither cancels the other. The correct conclusion is not a net score; it is that the same institutional and psychological features produce both, and that any tradition which cannot examine its own record is exhibiting exactly the failure that produced the worst of it.

What to carry from this page ​

Sometimes people dispute a claim that nobody can test. If they also hold the claim to be of the highest importance, they have no way to settle it except force. This is the pattern most specific to religion. It can appear in any field, including secular ones, so it helps to recognise it.

The boundary that produces internal trust is the same one that produces the outside. You do not get the first without the second, and knowing that is the only defence.

When authority answers to nobody outside itself, it tends to hide things. This happens every time, in every kind of institution.

The critics inside each tradition were always there. They were overruled. The means of correction exist inside every tradition in this Part. The only question is whether somebody with standing will use them.

Next: 12.9 — what, after eight chapters, the traditions actually agree on. It is smaller than the comfortable version and considerably more interesting.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet