Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

12.6 — East Asia: Confucius, Laozi, Shinto ​

In East Asia, people were asking a different question from the ones we have met so far.

The Indian and Abrahamic traditions ask what is ultimately real and how a person is released or saved.

The Chinese traditions mostly ask how people should live together, and treat the metaphysical question as either secondary or unanswerable.

And they are not exclusive. A Chinese family could and routinely did perform Confucian rites for the ancestors, consult a Daoist priest, and observe Buddhist practices, without anybody experiencing that as contradiction. 12.1's belief-organised versus practice-organised distinction is at its sharpest here.

Confucius ​

Kong Fuzi, roughly 551 to 479 BCE, in a period of political collapse and constant warfare.

He was a minor official who could not get the position he wanted, travelled from state to state trying to persuade rulers to adopt his ideas, was largely ignored, and taught students.

He said that he was passing on old wisdom, not inventing something new. He wanted to recover the practices of an earlier and better-ordered age.

The core ​

Five ideas, and they interlock.

Ren is usually translated as benevolence, humaneness, or human-heartedness. It is the central virtue. Confucius would not define it neatly. He gave different answers to different students, according to what each one needed. This is the same idea as adhikara in 9.3 and the teaching method of 6.1, now appearing in China.

Asked once, he gave the negative version of the golden rule: do not impose on others what you yourself do not desire.

Li — ritual, propriety, the correct forms. And this is the idea outsiders find hardest.

It covers ceremony, manners, the right way to address somebody, the correct conduct at a funeral, and the details of everyday courtesy.

Confucius says that the forms are not empty. Doing the right outward action shapes the inner attitude. You become respectful partly by acting respectfully, year after year.

Which is Aristotle's habituation (10.4) and 8.11's practice, and it is the same finding: the behaviour comes first.

Xiao — filial piety. Obligation to parents, living and dead, and by extension the whole structure of family relationships.

Junzi — the exemplary person. Originally meaning "son of a lord," and Confucius redefined it to mean a person of moral cultivation regardless of birth.

That redefinition is the same move as the Yaksha's answer (3.10) and the Buddha's ordination of a barber ahead of nobles (6.10). Three traditions, same century, same move: taking a word that meant high birth and redefining it as conduct.

The rectification of names. Confucius said that social disorder begins when words do not match reality. A ruler may not behave like a ruler. A father may not behave like a father. If names are not correct, he says, then language does not fit the truth of things. Then affairs cannot be carried on to success.

The honest problems ​

The system is hierarchical. The five relationships — ruler and subject, father and son, husband and wife, elder and younger brother, friend and friend — are four hierarchies and one equality.

And obligations run both ways in the theory — the ruler owes benevolence, the father owes care — and in practice the framework was used for a very long time to justify subordination, particularly of women.

And it produced an examination system that lasted over a thousand years, which was genuinely meritocratic in principle and produced a bureaucracy of enormous competence and enormous conservatism.

Daoism ​

And the deliberate opposite, from the same period.

The Dao De Jing, attributed to Laozi, of uncertain historicity, and the Zhuangzi, which is funnier and philosophically sharper.

The Dao ​

The way, the course, the pattern of how things are.

And the first line of the text tells you what you are dealing with: the dao that can be spoken is not the eternal dao.

A book that opens by saying its subject cannot be put into words, and then continues for eighty more chapters.

Wu wei ​

The central practical idea, usually translated "non-action" and better rendered as "effortless action" or "not forcing."

It does not mean doing nothing. It means acting in accordance with the grain of a situation rather than against it.

The images all point the same way. One is water, which is the softest thing, yet wears away rock. Another is the empty space in a bowl, which is the part that is useful. A third is the hub of a wheel, which is useful because it is empty.

Zhuangzi tells it as a story. A cook is cutting up an ox. His blade has not been sharpened in nineteen years. This is because he does not cut through bone. He finds the spaces that are already there and moves through them. He no longer looks with his eyes.

Which is the best description of expertise anybody has written. The novice hacks; the master finds the gaps.

The politics ​

And Daoism has one, and it is anti-Confucian.

Confucius wants correct forms, education and cultivation. Laozi says that is the problem: when the great dao was abandoned, benevolence and righteousness appeared.

The claim is that the need for elaborate morality is evidence that something has already gone wrong, the way a family that talks constantly about filial duty is a family with a problem.

And the political preference is for a small state, minimal government, and a ruler so light-handed that the people say afterwards that they did it themselves.

Zhuangzi ​

The best writer of the tradition, and two passages that everybody should know.

The butterfly. He dreamt he was a butterfly, and woke, and did not know whether he was a man who had dreamt he was a butterfly or a butterfly now dreaming he was a man. 9.8's three states argument, told as a joke.

The useless tree. A carpenter passes an enormous old tree and does not stop. The wood is worthless, because it is twisted and knotty and no good for anything. This is exactly why the tree has grown so large and so old. Every useful tree was cut down.

Which is a genuinely uncomfortable observation about what being valuable to other people costs you.

Shinto ​

Japan's indigenous tradition, and it is the least doctrinal thing in this Part.

Kami — usually translated "gods" and better as "spirits" or "presences."** Anything that inspires awe can be a kami: a waterfall, an ancient tree, a mountain, a rock, a remarkable person, an ancestor. They are not omnipotent, not necessarily moral, and are extremely numerous — the traditional phrase is "eight million kami," meaning uncountable.

And the central concern is not sin but purity. Contact with death, blood, illness or disorder produces impurity, and the response is ritual cleansing rather than repentance. The water basin at a shrine entrance, where you rinse your hands and mouth before approaching, is the everyday form of it.

There is no founder, no scripture in the Abrahamic sense, and very little doctrine.

And it coexists with Buddhism completely. The Japanese formula — Shinto for birth and marriage, Buddhism for death — is close to literally true, and most Japanese people participate in both and would not describe themselves as religious.

One more thing should be said. In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, the state reorganised Shinto. It turned Shinto into a tool of nationalism, with the emperor's divinity at its centre. This construction was taken apart after 1945. The older tradition and the post-war tradition are not the same as State Shinto. It is a mistake to mix them up.

What East Asia contributes ​

Three things this volume takes from it.

The forms shape the person. Confucian li, Aristotle's habituation, and 8.11's practice all say the same thing, and the Chinese version is the most detailed about how ordinary courtesy does the work.

Wu wei: find the gaps rather than cutting through bone. The cook's blade after nineteen years is the best image of mastery in this volume.

The useless tree. It is a true observation about the cost of being valuable. It is worth sitting quietly with it, and not hurrying past it.

What to carry from this page ​

Do not impose on others what you do not desire for yourself. The negative form is more usable than the positive one, because it does not assume everybody wants what you want.

If names do not match realities, nothing can be carried on to success. Watch for the word that has stopped describing the thing.

The need for elaborate morality is evidence that something has already gone wrong. Uncomfortable, and frequently correct.

And the master finds the spaces that are already there. The blade has not been sharpened in nineteen years.

Next: 12.7 — what fasting, pilgrimage and ritual actually do to a person, examined without either piety or dismissal.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet