Skip to content

Volume VIISpirit & Philosophy

12.3 — Why Bengal Has Durga, Maharashtra Has Ganesh, Kerala Has Onam ​

The same religion, and a Bengali family's most important week of the year is not the same week as a Maharashtrian family's, and neither is the same as a Malayali family's.

And the attachment is not casual. People who are indifferent to doctrine will travel across continents to be home for their festival, and will weep at it.

This chapter is about why.

Four mechanisms ​

And they operate together in every case.

One: the deity was already there ​

Most regional deities are older than the tradition that absorbed them (7.1, 12.2).

A local goddess of a hill, a river or a village, worshipped for centuries, is identified with a pan-Indian figure — she becomes a form of Parvati or Durga — and the identification is a merger rather than a replacement.

The practice continues. The name is now shared. The local specifics survive underneath.

Which is why the same goddess has completely different characteristics in two states, and why the ritual details are unique to each place.

Murugan in Tamil country is the clearest documented case (7.8). An older Tamil god of the hills, called Ceyon, joined with the northern god Kartikeya. The result is Tamil in every practical respect.

Two: geography and livelihood ​

A farming region's central festival is about the harvest. A coastal region's is about the sea. A region dependent on the monsoon has festivals timed to it.

Onam is a harvest festival in a rice-growing state. Pongal in Tamil Nadu is a harvest festival named after the dish that is cooked by boiling over, and the boiling over is the point. Baisakhi in Punjab is the wheat harvest.

Underneath the theology is an agricultural calendar, and the theology arrived later and attached itself to a date that already mattered.

Three: history and identity ​

And this is the mechanism that makes the bond so strong, and it is the least discussed.

A festival can be deliberately built into an identity, and two of the three cases here were.

Four: the form the practice takes ​

And this is what makes each one feel unique from inside.

Durga Puja is public, artistic and competitive. Ganesh Chaturthi is a procession. Onam is a meal.

Different senses make different attachments. What a person is really attached to is the sensory memory. It is the smell, the sound, the particular food, and the light at that time of year.

Durga Puja in Bengal ​

Five days in autumn, and it is not really comparable in scale to anything else in the region.

The story behind it is this. Durga is the warrior goddess. The gods combined their power to create her, so that she could defeat the buffalo demon Mahishasura. None of them could defeat him alone. She is shown in the middle of her victory, with ten arms and the demon at her feet.

Bengal adds a story of its own, and this is where the feeling lies. Durga is a married daughter who comes home to her parents for a few days. She brings her children with her. Then she leaves again.

That is why the last day is genuinely sad, and why the immersion of the image in the river is accompanied by weeping. The festival is structured as a visit from a daughter who has to go back.

In a culture where daughters married out and left, that is not a metaphor.

An elaborately constructed and decorated temporary pavilion housing a large sculpted image of a many-armed goddess
A Durga Puja pandal in Kolkata. The pandals are built new every year, by neighbourhood committees who compete on design, and the whole structure is dismantled after five days. The scale of the temporary construction is the festival's signature. Image: Wikimedia Commons.

And the practice is what makes it Bengali.

Pandals — enormous temporary pavilions, built by neighbourhood committees, competing on artistry, with themes that are frequently contemporary and sometimes political. Professional artists are commissioned. Awards are given. The city becomes an outdoor exhibition for five days and is dismantled afterwards.

The images are made in a single traditional quarter of north Kolkata. Families who have done this work for generations make them. They use clay from the Ganges. By tradition, the clay also includes earth from outside a courtesan's house. The reasoning is that men leave their virtue at that door, and it collects there. The central image of the festival must include earth linked to the most stigmatised women in society. This is a quiet and deliberate point.

And the immersion. The image is not permanent. It is made, worshipped, and dissolved in the river, which is 12.2's principle made completely explicit: the divine was invited in and is released.

The identity function is strong and it is historically specific. Durga Puja became a large public event in Bengal partly under colonial conditions, and it functioned as a mass gathering in a society where mass gatherings were watched.

Ganesh Chaturthi in Maharashtra ​

Ten days, in late summer, and the modern form has a documented origin.

Ganesh worship is ancient and household Ganesh Chaturthi is old.

The public form was built deliberately in the 1890s by Bal Gangadhar Tilak, the nationalist leader.

His reasoning was explicit. The colonial government restricted political assembly and did not restrict religious assembly. So he converted a household observance into a large public festival with processions, organisation, speeches, songs and committees.

The effect was what he intended. It became a mass organisation with a cover nobody could object to. It also had a social effect. The public festival crossed caste lines that household worship did not cross.

A workshop filled with rows of large unfinished sculpted elephant-headed figures
Ganesh images in production in Mumbai. The public form of the festival was deliberately built in the 1890s by Tilak, converting a household observance into a mass gathering at a time when religious assembly was permitted and political assembly was not. Image: Wikimedia Commons.

It ends the same way as Durga Puja. On the tenth day, the images go into the sea in enormous processions.

Two festivals, two states, both ending with a made image dissolved in water, and both carrying an identity function that was sharpened under colonial rule.

And a modern problem worth naming: plaster of Paris images and chemical paints do not dissolve and are ecologically damaging, and there are active campaigns and rules pushing back towards clay. A tradition adjusting to a consequence it did not previously have.

Onam in Kerala ​

Onam lasts ten days and falls in the harvest season. It is not only a Hindu festival. Hindus, Christians and Muslims across Kerala celebrate it together as a state festival.

And its story is the strangest in this chapter.

Mahabali was an Asura king (1.5) who ruled Kerala. His reign is remembered as perfect. There was no poverty, no deceit and no disease. There was no caste distinction, and everybody was equal.

He was so good that the gods became alarmed.

Vishnu came to him as Vamana, a dwarf brahmin, and asked for as much land as he could cover in three steps.

Mahabali granted it, despite being warned.

And Vamana grew, and covered the earth in one step and the heavens in the second, and asked where to place the third.

Mahabali offered his own head.

He was pushed down into the underworld. He was given one concession. He may return once a year to visit his people.

Onam is that visit.

What that story means ​

Read it plainly and it is remarkable.

The most beloved king in the region's memory is an Asura, deposed by a trick, by Vishnu, who is worshipped in the same region.

And the people's festival is for the deposed king rather than for the god who deposed him.

Kerala's most important festival is a celebration of a ruler who was removed for being too good, and it carries an explicit memory of an egalitarian society. It has been read politically for a very long time and continues to be.

The practice has several parts. A flower carpet is laid out each day, and it grows larger over the ten days. People wear new clothes. There are boat races, with crews of over a hundred rowers. There is also the Onam sadya, a vegetarian feast of many dishes. It is served on a banana leaf in a fixed order.

A festival whose central act is a meal, in a state, eaten by everybody.

Why the bond runs so deep ​

And the answer, which is the chapter's actual point.

It is not theological. Almost nobody's attachment to their festival is doctrinal.

Four things produce it.

Childhood sensory memory. The specific smell, the specific sound, the specific food, the specific quality of light in that month. These are laid down early and are not accessible to argument.

Annual repetition across a whole life. You have thirty or fifty instances of this, layered, with the people who were there each time — including the ones who are gone. A festival is a place where the dead are present, and 14.3 explains why that matters so much.

Collective participation. The whole street, city or state doing it at once. Volume VI covers what synchronised group activity does to people, and the effect is large and measurable.

Identity under pressure. Sometimes a practice marks you out. This can happen under colonial rule, in a diaspora (a community living far from its homeland), or as a minority. Such a practice becomes far more important to you than a practice nobody ever challenged. This is why the festival often matters more to somebody living abroad than to somebody at home.

What to carry from this page ​

The deity was usually there first, and was identified with a pan-Indian figure rather than replaced by one.

Underneath the theology there is nearly always an agricultural date that already mattered.

Two of these three festivals took their modern public form under colonial conditions, and identity under pressure is the strongest of the four mechanisms.

The attachment is sensory, repeated, shared with others, and full of the memory of the dead. So it is not helpful to argue with somebody about their festival. Their love for it was not built by argument, so argument does not reach it.

Next: 12.4 — three religions from one root, and what the actual differences are once the polemics are removed.

Combine chapters into one PDF

Pick the chapters you want. They print in the order you pick them.

Volume VII — Spirit & Philosophy
Part 1 — Reading a Sacred Story Honestly
Part 2 — The Ramayana
Part 3 — The Mahabharata
Part 4 — Krishna: The Complete Life
Part 5 — The Bhagavad Gita
Part 6 — The Buddha
Part 7 — Shiva, the Adiyogi
Part 8 — Karma, Dharma & the Six Enemies
Part 9 — Indian Philosophy
Part 10 — Western Philosophy
Part 11 — The Myths of the World
Part 12 — Faith, Religion & Festivals
Part 13 — Ethics
Part 14 — Meaning, Death & the Examined Life
Part 15 — The Science–Spirit Bridge
Part 16 — The Path: Becoming
Nothing picked yet